You can find this cynical, and bluntly honest film review at: http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/movies/2013/10/romeo_and_juliet_directed_by_downton_abbey_s_julian_fellowes_reviewed.html
"Romeo and Juliet," one of Slate's most recent film reviews by Dana Stevens, takes a harsh look at Hollywood's latest re-hashing of Shakespearean material. Diction, detail, and syntax are all used to make Stevens appear to be intellectually above the film, and to deliver a tired, jaded tone.
Stevens often switches between higher-end colloquial diction, and informal diction to create a separation between her and Romeo and Juliet. For example, when describing Hailee Steindfeld's looks, Stevens uses informal word-chains with a multitude of hyphens, such as "not-out-of-the-box," and "normal-girl-on-the-street." On their own, these dictional choices would give the piece an informal, down-to-earth tone. However, within the same paragraph (and seemingly within the same breath) Stevens whips out the words "impetuousness" and "petulant." The stark contrast between Stevens's formal and informal diction serves to make Stevens sound "above" such things as Romeo and Juliet, and gives the reader the impression that Stevens would rather be doing other things with her time.
The details Stevens uses to describe Romeo and Juliet remain almost exclusively dedicated to the film's aesthetics. When describing Douglas Booth (our friend Romeo), Stevens refers to his "model-handsome[ness]," "magazine-ready looks," and "polished . . . manner." Stevens's restraint from delving into the specifics of Booth's performance points to her feelings of jadedness towards today's aesthetically pleasing Hollywood. She's conveying the cynical point of view that popular film makers care nothing for the substance of story-telling, but only for the film's eye-candy factor.
Further along her review, Stevens bring up the beauty of Romeo and Juliet's locations, which span "a few . . . medieval Italian towns, . . . [which] are gorgeous." Later in the same paragraph, she suggests that it would be more worthwhile for the viewer to admire the beauty that "crowd[s] the walls behind" the characters, rather than focus on their "familiar travails . . . in the foreground" (Stevens). Again, Steven's clear focus on aesthetic details points to her jaded position on the lack of substance in today's films.
Throughout her piece, Stevens doesn't shy away from long sentences. For example, she opens the review with:
Carlo Carlei's Romeo and Juliet—a lush, conventional bodice-ripper of an adaptation with a screenplay (by Downton Abbey's Julian Fellowes) that borrows heavily from Shakespeare
without quite being Shakespeare—feels like a quant throwback to an earlier era in which a
little-known director could just up and film a Shakespeare play, without big stars or a
modern interpretive concept.
Stevens's use of such long sentences without abandon ensures that she comes across as the film's superior. If she'd chosen to restrain herself, and articulate her ideas in a more concise manner, she would have instead conveyed a tone of impartiality and commonality. By making the intentional syntactical choice of expressing her ideas through long-winded sentences, Stevens has created an atmosphere of intellectual superiority (ensuring that her readers would never confuse her with the type to willingly watch such a film).
Dana Stevens's "Romeo and Juliet" is a well-written review that takes advantage of diction, details, and syntax to portray the author as "above" the film, and create a tone of cynicism towards modern Hollywood.
Way to read closely, Simon! You identified the crap out of those techniques. Thanks for introducing me to Dana Stevens, by the way. I've just now read a couple of her reviews, and so far I'm really digging her taste. I've got to say, though, she doesn't seem to be quite as jaded as you're suggesting here. Try to find the good in people. Anyway, I think your analysis of her diction in this piece is pretty interesting. While I'll admit her tone here is less than serious, I'm not sure that the mixture of formal/informal diction she employs makes her sound like "she'd rather be doing other things with her time". Instead, I'm inclined to think that she inserted some nuggets of colloquial language in order to keep from sounding like a blow-hard, and to add an element of humor that would keep readers interested. Wouldn't you agree? Let me know what you think. With regards to Stevens's use of long sentences, I definitely catch your drift. However, I think your interpretation of that could have just as easily gone the other way. A lengthy sentence like the example you provided could be inspired by a sincere passion for a certain topic, instead of a jaded indifference. This makes it sort of hard to claim that a lack of breaks in her phrasing creates an atmosphere of intellectual superiority over her subject material. Maybe over her readers. Difference of opinion aside, I commend your rad literary skillz.
ReplyDeleteThanks man. What is this, a compliment treasure chest?
DeleteI do see how my interpretation is a tad negative. To be honest, I wasn't in a great mood when I wrote this. I should probably work towards separating my mood from my writing. Or should I? These are the questions.
Hi Simon.
ReplyDeleteNice analysis! And great examples too! I liked how you included the day-to-day language and all the hyphenated words. I definitely wouldn't have thought to do that. But I must agree with Eddie. I thought these informal words brought a more colloquial feel to the article and made it a tad bit less serious, but not quite disregarding the topic. I guess it could be a way to connect with the audience better. I wish you had added a bit more regarding the article's syntax. Yes I agree, a majority of the article is filled with long sentences, but I thought it was to make the article feel a little poetic and help it flow. Short sentences often make articles sound choppy. Like poems, the lengths keeps the ideas going on and reduces the cuts inside the articles. Where there are short sentences, I thought of those as emphasis. The author also uses a multitude of colons and dashes, to keep her ideas flowing while still separating the ideas. I did like how you went for a specific thesis as to the stance the author was taking and gave evidence supporting that. It's a good way to structure an essay for the AP exam. Nice job with that!
Simon, this was a well-written close reading analysis of the article.
ReplyDeleteThe juxtaposition between the informal and formal word choice was interesting and very well explained in your first body paragraph. I should be on the lookout for these rapid changes in diction when I read, because I did not find importance in that until you explained it.
I also have never fully understood the purpose of long sentence usage until your last body paragraph explained why the author employed it. I also liked how you explained why the author should not and did not use shorter sentences.
I feel like your paragraph on the articles use of detail was too short and not elaborate enough. If you provided more details (no pun intended), I think it would be better.
Nevertheless, this was a thorough and succinct analysis of the article.
Simon--I agree with you that it's important to keep your own pre-existing mood separate from the mood created by a piece of reading, but I also tend to find film review as a genre to reek of smugness, so I'm not convinced that you're wrong in your initial assessment of the tone. That's not to say we can't still enjoy a particular writer or that it makes him or her somehow suspect as a human being--it's just somehow a convention of film review to adopt a slightly jaded, superior, worldly persona. (Excellent work on this assignment, btw.)
ReplyDelete