In terms of keeping DIDLS in mind whilst analyzing literature, I'm not sure I've been totally successful. I think I still need to work on having a clear definition of each technique at my disposal. Instead, I feel like my analyzing is more "scatter-shot;" when I analyze, I'm like "hey look at this this might do this ooh that's exciting," and then only later can I go back and say "what I pointed out was a use of diction, which contributes to the work's message by . . ." This "method" isn't much of an improvement from what I was doing with literature before this class, which makes me feel like I'm not improving in this area enough.
Our readings on the Theatre of the Absurd and existentialism really lit my brain up. I'd sort of gone through life pretending that I knew what these things were, when in reality I was too lazy to do any research. Only through this required reading did I see how accurate my guesses were, and enlighten myself as to how close my views of the world were to these philosophies. The one that most surprised me with its specificity was the Theatre of the Absurd. I'd assumed that absurdism was just random silliness that held no connection to reality, when in actual fact it has a clear point of view, and strives to convey specific messages through its oft dismissed "nonsensicalness." This new information has forced me to look back on my critiquing ability, and not be so quick to paint something as merely "random nonsense."
Speaking of "random nonsense," I've very much enjoyed our analysis of The American Dream (yes, I understand that it's not random nonsense. I'm just creating smooth transitions). Upon our first reading, I couldn't have ever guessed how deep we'd tumble down the Albee rabbit-hole. The whole thing about Grandma being connected through The Great Gatsby's "owl-eyed man" through her owl-like "who . . . who" still blows my mind. The work has so many messages, and operates on so many different levels, that it would be impossible for me to refer to our discussion as anything less than a pure joy. I've also very much been stimulated by the connections I've found between Dream and modern works with absurdist messages (such as Paul Thomas Anderson's The Master, which opens, cycles back to, and ends on the exact same scene). Without our reading of this play, I would have never received such deep gratification over these connections.
Finally, I should talk about the reading on humor. Though I missed what was probably an enlightening discussion on its connection to Dream, I still found the information endlessly interesting. As much as I like to consider myself a fan of comedy, I'd never been brave enough to delve into the specific theories on what "funny" is. I've always been timid about "gutting the goose" of comedy, which can be an ethereal, unexplainable thing. Regardless, the packets we received do an admirable job at articulating some of the aspects of "funny." So good of a job, that I found connections between its theories and some of my favorite stand-up comedians. It's funny, for instance, when Kyle Kinane talks about how sad and lonely he is, because it's incongruous with the obvious fact that he's a successful working comedian playing sold-out shows most nights (though that's not the only reason. Kinane has an inherent humor about him that I can't explain.) I was also a little surprised that word play, even at the Shakespearian level, is considered "low humor."I suppose I'd been enjoying the unraveling of complex English distortion too much to remark on how devoid of "thoughtful laughter" it is.
Simon,
ReplyDeleteGreat reflection back on what we have learned in class. As you will read in my blogs, I completely agree with your pure joyful happiness talking about the American Dream and all the hidden meanings and symbols and just crazy stuff we have discovered. As far as being more able to recognize and apply DIDLS the first time reading, I think you’re getting there. Especially with all your highly intelligent analyses and ability to point that stuff out, you must be doing something right or else I wouldn’t believe most of the things you share in class discussions. I think you maybe should have talked about the AP testing just a tad because it played an important few days of discussion in class and it would have been fabulous to have your feedback on it.
Simon,
ReplyDeleteI'm glad the discussions in class and the packets Holmes provides us help you form a connection through pop culture and your everyday life. I really like how you also incorporated how messages in The American Dream "blow your mind" because I feel the same way! I can't remember if you were there or not, but we had a discussion about how Mommy and Daddy were children playing with dolls, and throughout that entire discussion I had chills. It's really neat that if you delve far enough into a piece of work you can unravel hundreds of hidden meaning and messages. When hearing you battle it out in our discussions I think you have the hang of DIDLS. Although always room for improvement, I'd still say you are grasping it quickly than others. Great analysis, Simon. :)
Simon,
ReplyDeleteAs weird as this may be, I found your response to be really enjoyable to read. I loved how you discussed the troubles you were having in connecting DIDLS to the works that we've been reading, especially since, for me, imagery is the toughest of all five to understand and apply. Your mention of Grandma's owl-like "who" and the connection to Fitzgerald's "Owl-eyed man" was also well appreciated, especially since I almost forgot about it! It definitely makes me think WOW Albee put a lot of thought into this play, and with all that thought, it came out to sound like a bunch of kids just talking nonsense. Your discussion on humor is also quite relatable to me, as I have never thought about how in-depth you could go in discussing the types of humor. I think that your response is very well thought out and, although there is always room for improvement, there is barely more you could do! Nice job!