Sunday, April 27, 2014

Response to Course Material

Last post, guys. We did it. I feel like I've landed on the moon. Or slowly puttered into fourth place. One of the two, for sure.

Ceremony, I'd say, was a good experience. We learned how to properly discuss the cultures of Native American tribes, which could very easily come in handy later in life. Reading Ceremony also opened my eyes to how casually racist many pieces of pop culture are towards Native Americans. I recently re-watched Pocahontas and Peter Pan (because contrary to popular belief, having a life is optional) and both dole out some strongly offensive material. Peter Pan features an extended sequence where the Lost Boys run into the most horrifyingly stereotypical "savage" tribe. It's bad. Pocahontas is racist on a much deeper level, I feel, because in its attempts to make the culture of a Native American tribe palatable for white, Western audiences, it homogenizes all the perceived tropes of "Native American belief," and totally misses the mark. Through its intention to "diversify the Disney universe," it horribly mangles the beliefs that many Native American tribes hold dear. And it also portrays a horrible period of time as positive, and alters the historical record entirely. This connects to Ceremony because it was only through our discussing of it that I became so aware of society's incorrect representation of Native Americans.

Now, Fifth Business. The reading is due on Tuesday, and I'll be honest with you guys, I have not yet finished the book. How much have I read? Not enough to make any connections, or state definitively how I feel about it. Does that defeat the purpose of this post? Maybe. But, I can comment on how much I look forward to devouring our last AP Lit book. Discussions will be fiery and intense, I'm sure, and I'm ready to take on the challenge. I'm also intrigued as to how much I can read in one sitting.

Our preparation for the AP Test has been wholly useful. We've reviewed multiple choice questions, done open and closed prompts, and actually had our work graded, as though it were the AP. This has assuaged my fears of the test a ton, and has bred in me the kind of blind confidence I'll need to do passingly well.

I feel as though I should address the whole year . . . it's been great. I've enjoyed the triumphs, the struggles, the anguish, the shame, and the embarrassment. All of it. This class has made me feel alive, and was difficult enough to give me at least the illusion of intelligence. Which is all you need to make it in this world.

So what have I learned? Sure, I've learned terms and analysis and DIDLS and atmosphere and books and stuff. But what I've really learned, is how to be a person. And that's the greatest gift of all.

Thursday, April 17, 2014

Summary and Analysis of Ceremony

Author: Leslie Marmon Silko, born in 1948, other works include Almanac of the Dead and Sacred Water

Setting: New Mexico, the late 1940s. As the work spans multiple years, many seasons take place. There are also some retellings of Laguna stories in poem form, which lack specific setting.

Characters
Tayo: A half-Laguna, half-white World War II veteran. Through his struggles with alcoholism, the traumas of war, and his conflicts with Laguna tradition, we discover that he is also an incarnation of the Sun spirit found in Laguna culture.

Betonie: A Laguna spiritual-healer who helps Tayo discover his role in saving the world from destruction.

Josiah: Tayo's Uncle, and a father-figure in many ways. He dies while Tayo is away at the war, though it is never revealed what the specific circumstances of his death are. He is the buyer of the hybrid cattle, making him crucial to the re-cycling of the Laguna stories.

Rocky: Tayo's cousin, who rejects Laguna values for the certainty of Western science. After dyeing at war with Tayo, Tayo is wracked with guilt over letting the better cousin die.

Harley: A WWII veteran, and friend to Tayo.

Emo and Pinkie: Acting under the guise of friendship with Tayo, they are actually witches bent on enacting destruction upon the world.

Auntie: Rocky's mother, and Tayo's aunt. A devout catholic, she's obsessed with popularity, and frequently shames Tayo for letting Rocky, the better one, die in the war.

Old Grandma: Calm and wise, she champions Laguna tradition.

Yellow Woman: Taking the form multiple characters, the Night Swan included, she is the spirit of the earth. She frequently has sex with Tayo, and steers him in the correct path.




Saturday, March 15, 2014

Response to Course Material

Brushing off the dust of our heated involvement with Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, we began to slowly work through Ceremony on our own time.

I enjoy the isolated reading experience of Ceremony less than our communal readings of every other work thus far. Interacting and engaging with the class as we endured an initial exposure to these works felt special to me, which I didn't realize until I began consuming Ceremony alone. Like, super alone. The kind of alone that begets, dare I say, loneliness.

But not so lonely that I can't declare my enjoyment of Ceremony! I love how smoothly the work flows. It oozes, like a chocolate syrup that deals with alcoholism and social displacement. The book that comes closest, in my mind, is Jazz by Toni Morrison (which, full disclosure, I never actually finished. 
I was but a wee sophomore, and Jazz was quite far beyond my literary capabilities). However, my point still stands. Morrison's use of fragments and long, billowing sentences constructed a smoothness to the narrative that Ms. Silko seems to capture. 

I'd be foolish not admit the strong connection I find with Sherman Alexie. Though I've never been a huge fan of his writing, Alexie has been highly influential in bringing the Native American experience to the forefront of modern American literature. This rings true in Silko's storytelling as well, shedding light on the long term effects of a people's subjugation.

We also began looking back on our previously discussed works through different critical lenses, an activity I found enjoyable. I had to dust off some of the background info I gathered from American Lit, and was joyfully enlightened twice on what Literary Darwinism is. I'm not sure how it could apply to anything we've already discussed, but I'm wrong pretty much all the time. I look forward to that future discussion, if it ever happens.



Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompts, Part Two: 2012

2012. “And after all, our surroundings influence our lives and characters as much as fate, 
destiny or any supernatural agency.” Pauline Hopkins, Contending Forces 
Choose a novel or play in which cultural, physical, or geographical surroundings shape 
psychological or moral traits in a character. Then write a well-organized essay in which you 
analyze how surroundings affect this character and illuminate the meaning of the work as a 
whole. Avoid mere plot summary.

In William Shakespeare's Hamlet, Hamlet's psychological traits are shaped by his royal surroundings. The strictures of politics among Hamlet's family make him feel isolated and paralyzed, transforming his demeanor and tilting him towards murderous urges. Through this shaping of Hamlet's traits, Shakespeare warns that violent revenge can only have negative consequences.

Hamlet's family members often have to wear two different "masks" during their daily life. One represents their public persona, while the other represents their private persona. Seeing as they were often surrounded by court officials, those of high rank in Elsinore had to often adopt completely different views and opinions when speaking to one another. Hamlet, seeing the falseness and denial of intimacy in his family, is driven to frustration and depression by the lack of honest communication in the castle. It is also through this structure of royalty, that Hamlet is denied the experience of love. Ophelia, whom Hamlet impregnated in an act of true love, entirely loses support from Hamlet due to political circumstances out of their control. Had Hamlet been able to spend time with Ophelia and make arrangements to raise the child, he would likely have not been so willing to devote his thoughts to only bloody deeds. Rather, Ophelia drowns herself out of shame and despair, leading Hamlet drown out his former sense of reason and rationale.

For Hamlet, the consequences of his psychological degradation were vast. The scope of his failure is so broad, that it leads to the death of the entire court of Elsinore, and places Denmark into the hands of a rival price without a single shot fired. By comparing the cause and effect of Hamlet's trait changes, the meaning of Hamlet emerges. Shakespeare was indicting the use of violent revenge as a means of justice, and by proxy the mental scarring that politics can inflict. The paralyzing properties of Elsinore lead Hamlet to crave violent revenge, and thus facilitate the meaning of the work. In contrast to Fortinbras, who heeded his Uncle's advice in avoiding violent confrontation, and only visited Elsinore with peaceful intentions, Hamlet emerged the loser. Fortinbras was given the ultimate reward for his actions, and Hamlet the ultimate punishment. Had it not been for Denmark's royal paralyzation on Hamlet, the ultimate message of Hamlet would have been lost.

In conclusion, in William Shakespeare's Hamlet, Hamlet suffers from a psychological shift brought on by the environment of impersonality and politics in Elsinore. This tilts him towards feelings of violent revenge, allowing Shakespeare to communicate that bloody vengeance is not a morally justifiable course of actions.


Thursday, March 6, 2014

Summary and Analysis of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead

Author: Tom Stoppard, born in Czechoslovakia in 1937, author of Jumpers, Travesties, co-writer of the films Shakespeare in Love and Brazil, to name a few.

Setting: The stage. Many (perhaps all) characters of Ros and Guil are aware of the stage they preside upon, and the audience they're performing for. The play takes place during the time of performance, and is independent from weather, as it's an indoor affair. The fictional world of the stage takes place in Hamlet's Denmark, but the audience is made painfully aware that the stage is the true setting.

Plot: Act One
  • Ros and Guil appear on stage, playing a game of coin-flips. They've been playing the game for some time, and the result is consistently "heads."
  • Guil wrestles with the logical inconsistency of their situation, while Ros doesn't really care.
  • The two uncover the memory of being called upon by a man on a horse, but they have no memory of their mission.
  • A band of Tragedians, led by the Player, comes on stage. It becomes clear that they're actually offering themselves up as prostitutes.
  • Guil, frustrated, challenges the Player to the coin game, and beats the Player badly.
  • The Player initiates the beginning of a play, and Ros and Guil are immediately whisked into the world of Hamlet, where we're introduced to Hamlet and Ophelia acting out the scene where Hamlet grabs Ophelia's hand all dramatically and stuff.
  • Claudius and Gertrude enter, and tell Ros and Guil of their mission, to find out why Hamlet's acting crazy.
  • Ros and Guil, who know their lines perfectly, are both confused and frustrated after the scene ends.
  • After some witty banter and a hiatus, the two begin a game of questions, in which rhetoric, synonyms, repetition, statements, grunts, and non-sequiturs are considered "fouls."
  • The two obsess over trying to remember each other's names, and then role-play their conversation with Hamlet.
  • After pondering why they were even sent for in the first place, Hamlet and Polonius enter, initiating Hamlet's first scene with Ros and Guil.
Act Two
  • Hamlet finishes his conversation with Ros and Guil, while the same Tragedians from before enter as the "Players" from Hamlet.
  • Ros and Guil, after the stage has cleared, discuss how poorly they handled the conversation, and become engrossed in trying to discern the direction of the sun and wind.
  • The Tragedians come on stage. The Player is frustrated at Ros and Guil for their abandonment in the middle of the Tragedians' performance, and laments the difference between actors and the rest of humanity.
  • The Player advises Ros and Guil to relax, and tries to prod them along in figuring out Hamlet's plot.
  • The Tragedians leave, and Ros and Guil ponder death.
  • Gertrude and Claudius enter, and have quick interaction with Ros and Guil, in which they are told to continue their mission.
  • The Tragedians come back on, and force Ros and Guil to watch their rehearsal of Gonzago (which is really a re-enactment of Hamlet), with the Ros and Guil equivalents being hanged in the same attire the actual Ros and Guil are dressed in. (During this show, Claudius walks on and talks of his plans to send Hamlet to England).
  • The two are on the cusp of making a connection, then Guil rants about the difference between stage death and real death.
  • There's a blackout, and Hamlet fast-forwards to the King's show of guilt at the performance of Gonzago.
  • The two get a moment to themselves, then Claudius comes on to deliver the news that Hamlet's killed Polonius, and that they're assigned to find Hamlet and recover the body.
  • The two struggle to carry out these orders, then Hamlet comes back on, insulting and making fun of Ros and Guil. 
  • Claudius comes on, orders Ros and Guil to retrieve Hamlet, and receives Hamlet by a separate escort. 
  • The two overhear some of Hamlet's conversation with the Soldier, and resolve to actually leave the stage.
Act Three
  • They wake up in pitch darkness, and hear boat sounds. 
  • They contemplate their situation, and notice Hamlet sleeping upstage.
  • Neither of them know what to do once they reach England, and begin to role-play their interaction with the English king.
  • During this game, they read Claudius's letter ordering Hamlet's execution.
  • Hamlet, hearing this, replaces the letter with his own while Ros and Guil sleep.
  • The Tragedians pop out of some barrels, and the ship is overrun with invisible pirates.
  • The two role play their interaction with the English king again, this time reading the new letter (prompting Ros and Guil's execution), cuing the Tragedians to carry out this order.
  • Guil, out of frustration, stabs the Player, supposedly killing him.
  • The Player gets up, reveals that it was a fake knife, and prompts the Tragedians to enact Hamlet's final deaths.
  • Ros and Guil, left alone on stage, come to terms with their deaths, and disappear.
  • We're left with Horatio's concluding speech.
Characters: Rosencrantz
  • The least intelligent of the two.
  • Is content with playing games.
  • Lives entirely in the moment, due to his almost non-existent memory.
  • Sometimes takes on Guildenstern's philosophizing, but is largely passive and dumb.
  • Is relieved when his death comes.
  • Is trapped on the stage, with an awareness of the audience
Guildenstern
  • The more intelligent of the two.
  • Has a more intact memory, and a penchant for contemplation and questioning.
  • Occasionally takes on Ros's stupidity, but is largely anxious and afraid.
  • Desperately tries to apply logic to his situation, but fails.
  • Resolves to do better "next time" at his death.
  • Is imprisoned on the stage, with an awareness of the audience.
Player
  • Can walk on and off stage as he chooses.
  • References other times he's met Ros and Guil, implying that he's been through the same cycle before.
  • Exists in a level of reality separate from Ros and Guil's, but not quite our reality.
  • Serves as Stoppard's mouthpiece in condemning art's treatment as commerce.
  • Has a complete intellect, unlike Rose and Guil.
Hamlet
  • Acts out some scenes not actually in Hamlet.
  • Also demonstrates an awareness of the audience, implying that he has feelings of persecution similar Ros and Guil.
Narrative Voice: 
  • The story is not being told by a specific person or character, as the work is a play.
  • The story isn't being told in a specific time period, as it exists on the stage of its performance. The time of the story is the time of viewing.
  • The narrative is chronological, following Ros and Guil's experiences in real time, while an accelerated version of Hamlet occurs around them.
  • The language of the narrative involves largely colloquial diction (except for the excerpts from Hamlet, which is elevated), and short sentences. Ros and Guil will occasionally break into long, articulate speeches, but their conversations are mostly clipped phrases. 
Style: Point of View

Stoppard takes on a critical, yet playful point of view in Ros and Guil. While on one hand, he comments harshly on the public's treatment of art as commerce, he couples it with delightful wordplay and silly sex jokes. Stoppard also criticizes humanity's near-worship of Shakespeare, and suggests that language serves to obscure emotion, but all through the lens of silliness and occasional slapstick.

Tone

Ros and Guil deftly switches between solemnity and silliness, making it hard to pin down one specific tone. Overall, I'd assert that the play has a light, playful tone. Ros and Guil often pass the time by playing games and making puns, and seem to be constantly cushioning their philosophy with humor. In many instances the play doesn't take itself seriously, somewhat undercutting any dark overtones.








Sunday, February 16, 2014

Response to Course Material

I think it's safe to say that the class breathed a collective sigh of relief as we wrapped up our discussion of Hamlet. We all started the experience as small, confused children, and emerged as wizened, experienced Lit students.

And with this newfound experience, we sank our teeth into Rozencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead by Tom Stoppard. My experience with R & G was initially quite confusing. I had difficulty following the conversational patter between our titular heroes, and couldn't quite appreciate much of the play's humor. Much of this probably had to do with the quick pace we had assumed in reading through the piece. 

The film, however, "iced the cake," if you will. I love the film. Seeing Stoppard's vision put to life excited me in ways I never expected. My feelings towards R & G can now only be described as pure, unadulterated love. The play and film scratch an itch I never knew I had, if that makes any sense. I find everything abut Stoppard's voice, style, delivery, and tone absolutely delicious. Pouring over the text again has been nothing but a positive experience.

Other than R & G's obvious connection to Hamlet, I found more connections to some other Shakespearian works. Much Ado About Nothing, for example, shares much of the playfulness of R & G. They both also derive much of their humor from wordplay, and are forthcoming in admitting that they shouldn't be taken seriously.

The work also reminded me of, in a way, Back to the Future Part II. In the film, Marty McFly uses his time machine to influence the events of the first film, operating behind the scenes, to preserve the reality of the first movie. The film sort of eats itself, funding the humor in an increasingly complicated situation. Marty reminds me of the Player, in that they both work "backstage" to preserve a certain reality. The Back to the Future films are also silly comedies, intended to not be taken seriously. R & G is (arguably) the same thing.

We also, as a class, did some rigorous work with Open Prompts. Though I'm glad we received extra practice and instruction on the matter, our class time in the computer lab was stressful, and I'd rather not have a repeat experience. I guess our intro paragraphs should just suck less.

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompts, Part Two: 2009

2009. A symbol is an object, action, or event that represents something or that creates a range of associations beyond itself. In literary works a symbol can express an idea, clarify meaning, or enlarge literal meaning. Select a novel or play and, focusing on one symbol, write an essay analyzing how that symbol functions in the work and what it reveals about the characters or themes of the work as a whole. Do not merely summarize the plot.

In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, many symbols are employed to enrich and enhance the play's literary meaning. Prominent among these, is the tape recorder. The tape recorder functions as a foil for Willy Loman, provides the turning point that sets Willy on the path to suicide, and reveals the true nature of Willy's failure as a human being.

The tape recorder, as Willy astutely observes, is everything Willy isn't. As Willy's boss insists on playing tapes of his young children, he reveals the qualities of the recorder. It can perfectly recall past events, it performs reliably, it serves as a container for the love of a family, it's young and shiny, and it can only be afforded by the wealthy. On the other hand, Willy's has a deteriorating mind, is an unreliable father, has a family that's falling apart, is old, and has little money to his name. The recorder, serving as stark contrast to Willy, further enhances and deepens the reader's understanding of Willy's character.

It is at Willy's interaction with the tape recorder, that he resolves to follow through on his suicidal urges. He sees, plain as day, the tremendous level at which he's a failure. He's reminded of his negative qualities, and is treated by his boss as though he's of lower authority than the machine. Willy's boss gives the recorder conversational priority, insisting that Willy wait for it to finish before speaking. Later, Willy proves himself incapable of operating the machine, acting nervous and scared. This moment of "old-world" and "new-world" colliding is what pushes Willy over the edge. The machine, to Willy, represents the new generation pushing out the old, leaving him no choice but to remove himself entirely.

The tape recorder reveals the true nature of Willy's failure, because it is through qualities of normality that he's pushed to suicide. The ability to remember, to love, and to perform reliably are all qualities most would attribute to a normal human being. In Willy's case, however, they are things he's entirely incapable of reaching, due to a life being spent in the wrong manner. Willy's lived out his days pining to be as successful as the mythical hyper-masculine figures he clings to, leaving him with the inability to connect emotionally with a person, or accept kindness from those in a better position. It is through the revelations of the tape recorder, that the reader fully comes to terms with these character traits.

The tape recorder serves as a paramount symbol in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman. It serves as an effective foil for Willy, facilitates Willy's turn to suicide, and shows the true extent to which Willy is a failure. Without the tape recorder, Salesman would be a less rich, deep, and thought-provoking work.

Friday, January 31, 2014

Summary and Analysis of Hamlet

Author: William Shakespeare, born in Stratford-upon-Avon in 1564, author of Romeo and Juliet, Macbeth, and Othello (to name a few).

Setting: Denmark, no specifics on season, purposely not set within a specific time period, few specifics on weather

Plot:
Act One:

  • Horatio and guards see the ghost of Old Hamlet, former king of Denmark. The ghost doesn't speak
  • Claudius explains that young Fortinbras is leading an attempt to reclaim Old Hamlet's land, sends ambassadors. 
  • Laertes is granted leave to France, while Hamlet is denied access back to Wittenburg.
  • Hamlet is grieving over his father's death, Claudius and Gertrude tell him to get over it.
  • Hamlet's unhappy with the short amount of time between his father's death and Gertrude's marriage.
  • Horatio tells Hamlet of the ghost, Hamlet wants to see it.
  • Ophelia is told by both Polonius and Laertes not to fall in love with Hamlet.
  • Hamlet, Horatio, and Marcellus visit the ghost, who only wishes to speak with Hamlet.
  • The ghost explains that he died by Claudius's hand, and commands Hamlet to avenge his death.
Act 2:
  • Polonius sends someone to france to watch over Laertes
  • Ophelia's visited by Hamlet, who acts seemingly crazy
  • Polonius wrongly assumes that Hamlet's madness is due to his love for Ophelia
  • Gertrude and Claudius tell Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to spy on Hamlet
  • Polonius tells Ophelia that Hamlet's madly in love with her
  • Hamlet finds out that R and G are spying on him
  • Hamlet plans to reveal his uncle's guilt by staging a play with a plot similar to Hamlet's situation
Act 3:
  • R and G can't find the reason for Hamlet's madness
  • Claudius and Polonius decide to spy on Hamlet's interaction with Ophelia
  • Hamlet ends up declaring that he never loved Ophelia, gets crazy mad
  • Claudius decides that there's more to Hamlet's madness, orders him to be sent to England
  • The play is put on, Claudius shows guilt
  • Hamlet's asked to see Gertrude
  • R and G are to take Hamlet to England
  • Polonius wants to spy on Hamlet and Gertrude
  • Hamlet happens across Claudius praying, but doesn't take to opportunity to enact revenge, as he wants to be sure Claudius will go to hell.
  • Polonius spies on Hamlet and Gertrude
  • Hamlet scares Gertrude, hears Polonius, and stabs at him, thinking it's Claudius
  • Hamlet explains the errors to Gertrude's ways
  • The Ghost appears, reminds Hamlet of his mission.
  • Only Hamlet can see the Ghost, Gertrude is convinced of Hamlet's madness
Act 4:
  • Gertrude informs Claudius of Polonius's death
  • Claudius orders R and G to immediately send Hamlet to England
  • Hamlet won't reveal where Polonius's body is, sees Fortinbras's army as he's being sent away
Act 5:
  • Two clowns dig up Yorick's grave to make room for the now dead Ophelia
  • Hamlet accepts his death, duels with Laertes, kills Claudius, and leaves the Kingdom completely open to Fortinbras's takeover.
Characters:
 Hamlet
  • Protagonist
  • Around thirty years old
  • Son of Old Hamlet, former King of Denmark
  • Next in line for the throne
  • Is caught in a religious conflict between his (assumably Catholic) home, and the Protestant values of Wittenburg
  • Is in a romantic relationship with Ophelia, and arguably his mother
  • Constantly contemplate's suicide
Ophelia
  • Sister of Laertes, daughter of Polonius
  • Romantically involved with Hamlet
  • Possibly goes crazy, may have been impregnated by Hamlet
  • Drowns, possible suicide
Claudius
  • King of Denmark, murderer of his brother Old Hamlet
  • Marries Gertrude soon after Old Hamlet's death
  • Puts politics over family matters, though still plots to kill Hamlet
  • Is slain by Hamlet
Gertrude
  • Widow of Old Hamlet, wife of Claudius, mother to Hamlet
  • Queen of Denmark
  • Incestuous in her relationship with her brother-in-law and through her possible Oedipal relationship to Hamlet
  • Is killed by a cup of poison during Hamlet and Laertes's duel
Laertes
  • Son of Polonius, brother of Ophelia
  • Leaves to France
  • Blames Hamlet for his sister's death, used used as a pawn in Claudius's murder scheme
  • Is killed by Hamlet in their duel
Polonius
  • Father of Ophelia and Laertes
  • Right-hand-man to the King
  • Often pretends to be a fool, to disguise his position of immense power
  • Is killed by Hamlet while spying on him and Gertrude
Horatio
  • The only trustworthy character
  • Best friends with Hamlet
  • Survives at the play's end to retell the events of Elsinore
Narrative Voice
  • The play isn't told from the point of view of a specific narrator
  • The play unfolds chronologically
  • Shakespeare employs long sentences in iambic pentameter, utilizes elevated diction
Style:
Point of View:
Shakespeare takes on a critical point of view in Hamlet. He comments harshly on the monarchical system of government, by portraying both Hamlet and Ophelia as characters paralyzed by their royal duties. Shakespeare also takes an explicit stance against revenge, as he serves the Court of Elsinore the ultimate punishment for their revenge schemes, while Fortinbras (who came to Elsinore with peaceful intentions) was rewarded with the throne of Denmark.

Tone:
Hamlet has a dark and morbid tone. Hamlet's already in a terribly dark place before he meets the Ghost, and afterwards is launched into a downwards spiral of suicidal thoughts, murderous urges, lost loved ones, and finally, death. Despite Hamlet's efforts to make the most morally correct decision possible, it is through his indecision that he ultimately fails his charge and causes the death of the entire court. Ophelia, pregnant with Hamlet's child, sees her relationship with Hamlet end, driving her to cry for help through pseudo-madness, and eventually commits suicide. Characters are seldom rewarded for their actions, and instead receive punishment from forces beyond their control.

Imagery:
Much of Hamlet's imagery comes from nature, such as Ophelia drowned in a river, Yorick's dug-up skull, and Old Hamlet being poisoned in his garden. Imagining Hamlet coming across the skull of his true father evokes feelings of horror and sadness in the reader. The image of Ophelia floating dead in a river makes the reader feel pain and sorrow. The imagery of Hamlet tends to be focused towards death, which alerts the audience that they should be paying attention to the causes and effects of death in the play.

Symbolism:
Claudius's literal act of pouring poison into Old Hamlet's ear symbolizes the giving of false information to a figure of high authority. For example, Polonius is cited to have the "ear" of the king, giving him cause to behave below his true intelligence. This dishonesty is "poison" in the ear of Claudius. Having Rosencrantz and Guildenstern unwillingly lie to Hamlet, taking advantage of his emotions for political reasons, is another example of "poison" in Hamlet's ear.

Yorick's skull symbolizes the death of any normalcy in Hamlet's life. Yorick was the only parental figure to build an emotional bond with Hamlet, and his final "appearance" coincides with the death of Ophelia, a woman he loved. Upon seeing the skull, Hamlet muses upon the universality and inevitability of death, and realizes that all men, regardless of the life they led, will end up buried. Hamlet sees the skull, and is reminded of the happiness he used to share with Yorick, highlighting the anger and sorrow he currently feels.

Quotes:
"To be or not to be—that is the question" (Act 3, Sc. 1).
Though undoubtedly the most famous line of the play, and the one that pops into everyone's head when one brings up Hamlet, it highlights an important conflict of the play. Hamlet's constantly wrestling with his suicidal urges, and how they coincide with his conflicting religious beliefs. The quote also leads into an idea important to the play: the fear people have for the unknown of death keeps people from ending painful lives.

"Something is rotten in the state of Denmark" (Act 1, Sc. 5).
Another famous line, this quote quickly establishes an important idea. The court of Elsinore is rotten from corruption, incest, and murder, and it's Hamlet's divine charge to cleanse the Denmark of its rotting portions. Though Hamlet and the Ghost believe this is best done through the killing of Claudius, it is, in truth, accomplished through the death of every member of the court, leaving the country open to rule by Fortinbras (an uncorrupted politician).

Theme Statement: In Hamlet, Shakespeare warns that when you don’t know who you are you are unable to effectively exercise moral judgement.


Hamlet's core struggle throughout the play arises from his lack of identity. As he exercises crippling indecision, he reveals that he's unfamiliar with his own identity. As a result, Hamlet is unwilling to enact revenge on his father's death (the moral choice at Shakespeare's time), leading to the eventual death of the entire Court of Elsinore. Having the play's title be Hamlet's name, lends further credence to the notion that Hamlet's lack of identity is the driving force of the play. Hamlet's indecision also leads to Ophelia's suicide. Had Hamlet been able to coherently state his position and communicate effectively with Ophelia, Ophelia would've likely not felt despair to the point of suicide. Hamlet, again, failed to make the moral choice. Much of Hamlet's imagery relates to death. Death, from a religious standpoint, is the ultimate motivator to lead a moral, sin-less life. As Hamlet journey's through his own vague darkness, he's being constantly reminded of the possible punishment being offered by death. Yorick's skull, for instance, laments the notion that perhaps Hamlet's indecision will have no effect on his post-death placement, adding further confusion to his troubled soul. Immediately following this incident, Hamlet has a horrible outburst in the grave of Ophelia, again linking Hamlet's confusion to his lack of identity.



Monday, January 20, 2014

Response to Course Material

It feels like we haven't done much in Lit since the last "Response to Course Material" post, but my feelings are likely influenced by the countless school days missed, whether due to snow or music events. Regardless, we did further discuss Hamlet, and managed to form a theme statement. I saw the formation of the theme statement daunting. It seemed to loom over my head as I read and annotated. But the process was, thankfully, a lot smoother than I anticipated. I'd chalk that up to our literary experience, and maybe some less active voices than usual.

I've recently begun re-watching Mad Men, a show centered around a 1960s New York advertising agency. It's a well crafted piece of television, dealing with the numerous struggles of surviving in an emotionally closed-off, bigoted world. Since our Hamlet discussions, I've noticed some connections. Mad Men often displays the differences between the public face and the private face, displaying the constant posturing and competition between men. It also very delicately carries dialogue that conveys double meanings; the characters of the show very rarely communicate with the words they're saying. They often speak in elaborate metaphors, much like the characters of Hamlet. The way Roger Sterling apologizes to Don Draper for hitting on his wife through the unexplained analogy of cars parking in the wrong garages feels very similar to Ophelia's communication through "crazy" babbling.

Sunday, January 12, 2014

Open Prompts, Part Two: 2004

2004. Critic Roland Barthes has said, “Literature is the question minus the answer.” Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes’ observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author’s treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.

In Edward Albee's play The American Dream, many questions are raised in regards to society. A large, dominating question of the work is: is society beyond saving? Albee seems to imply some answers, but leaves much up to reader interpretation. Albee's treatment of this question affects the reader's understanding of the play's meaning. Albee treats this question through Grandma's final exit, through the last interaction between Mommy and Young Man, and through the role sexual attraction plays in the work's conclusion.

By the end of The American Dream, the readers are treated to a fourth-wall breaking moment from Grandma. She exits the realm of the play, and interacts with the audience. What does this say about society's chances of being saved? It seems to imply that society still has hope, as Grandma was able to escape the hellish reality she was trapped in. Society can indeed save itself from the perils of miscommunication and endless competition. This affects one's understanding of the work by catapulting it to a new level of absurdism. If Grandma had merely "escaped" by leaving the apartment, the impact of Albee's implication would not be nearly as strong as it is now.

The last interaction between Mommy, Daddy, and the Young Man involves a celebration of "satisfaction." Right afterwards, however, Mommy complains that the wine they're drinking doesn't taste good, thus immediately extinguishing any hopes of these characters achieving their goals. This scenario answers the question of society's redemption negatively; The American Dream, based on this portion, implies that society has no hope for redemption. Human beings invent their own problems and obstacles, and shall therefore never overcome their flaws. This treatment affects the reader's understanding of the work in a depressing fashion. It adds a sour note to the play, and pulls readers towards drawing nihilistic conclusions.

The device of The American Dream's conclusion is the Young Man. He temporarily fills the void in Mommy's life, and allows Grandma to exit the story. But, he was granted access into the house initially because of Grandma's intense sexual attraction to him. What does this say about society's redemption? It implies that any redemption will be based on lower desires, such as sex. If Grandma wasn't so initially enthralled with the Young Man's aesthetics, she likely would've closed the door on him quickly. Instead, she was stunned speechless by his looks, and thus was granted enough time to explain his importance to the story. The affects one's understanding of the play by showing how dominated the characters are by sexual desire. It tacks on the notion that, regardless of intentions, all people, wise or naive, are submissive to their basest desires.

The American Dream by Edward Albee proposes the question: is society beyond redemption? By including Grandma's ascension, the final interaction between Mommy and the Young man, and the role sexuality played in concluding the work, Dream gives ambiguous and contradicting answers. Albee's treatment of this question affects the meaning of the work in many ways, leaving much up to the interpretation of the reader.