Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompts, Part One: 2006 Student Answers Question 2

2A: The student begins his/her response strongly with a direct address to the prompt, arguing that "Wilde sheds light on both the characters' underlying ideals and the sort of society that the three of them live in" through "the use of a mundane situation" in which the "characters interact with each other" and share "their opinions." The student proceeds to strongly support his/her argument with specific evidence regarding "Lady Windmere, Lord Darlington, and the Duchess of Berwick," suggesting a strong understanding of the source material. The student stayed consistently on task, citing the "gossip" among the characters as "one example of how trivial their high English society can be." He/she later cites "the women's perception of Lord Darlington . . . [as] highlight[ing] the shallow and critical nature of the society the characters live in." Though more literary techniques could have been explored, the students clear comprehension of the messages hidden in Wilde's dialogue serve excellently in upholding his/her argument. This is a high-quality essay. 

2B: The student begins well with an on-point thesis statement, but doesn't further elaborate on his/her argument well (within the introductory paragraph). As the response continues, the student cites good, specific textual examples to support his/her thesis, but only demonstrates a surface-level understanding of their meanings. Perhaps in some form of compensation, the student continues on to include a total of four specific examples, but each remain undeveloped in terms of his/her thesis. The student concludes with a solid re-statement of the argument. Though the student stayed on task and wrote in an organized fashion, the content of his/her supporting arguments fails to demonstrate a full understanding of the source material, and makes his/her argument feel weak. I agree with the AP Grader in asserting that fewer, but more thoroughly developed, arguments would have served the student better. This is an essay of mid to low quality. 

3C: The student begins with a non-specific thesis that has little to do with the prompt. By only stating that "one can infer the values the characters [possess]" by "reading Lady Windermere's Fan," he/she has completely left out any comment on the nature of the characters' society (which is an exclusion of half the prompt). The student gives a scatter-shot analysis of the Duchess of Berwick and Lord Darlington's character traits, centered around three quotes. His/her inclusion of the quotes was bereft of any in-depth analysis of their subtle nuance and meaning, implying little comprehension of the source material. The student does stick to his/her misguided thesis by stating many "values," but most of his/her claims lack any support ("[The Duchess of Berwick] also enjoys to be a nagging wife.") The student comes close to the prompt by writing that "in society people don't value marriage anymore," but is far removed from any concrete evidence. The concluding paragraph has little relation to the original thesis. This is an essay of poor quality. 


4 comments:

  1. Thoughtful critiques, Simon! I'm noticing a trend in the arrangement of these essays...it seems like the most exemplary sample always comes first. It'd be nice if they'd shake it up once in a while. You know, to keep us guessing. Anyway, there's not much to say about that first one, other than mentioning my jealousy of that student's ability to hammer out an essay of that quality in forty minutes. I peeked down at the AP grader's comments. That student got an 8. What do you think is the difference between an 8 and an 9? In other words, what specifically could the student have done to achieve a perfect score? Is it even possible? These are the questions, Simon. These are the questions. You didn't mention any of the student's gross overstatements in your critique of the second essay. I thought they weakened his position by making it seem like he was making something out of nothing, which is partially true, considering how he kept recycling the same arguments. Did you notice those, or am I being overly critical? Drop me a comment below if you get the chance, nothing like a little friendly discourse.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wouldn't say the second student had gross overstatements-- more like broad generalizations. There's not much backbone for me to go one, as I'm not enough the scholar to have familiarized myself with Wilde's work (though I feel affirmed through the AP Grader's non-mention of gross overstatements).
      Naw, you're not being overly critical. You're just a quick witted guy. Maybe too quick for your own good.

      Delete
  2. Hey Simon.

    So like Eddie, I believe you did a closed prompt instead of an open prompt, which will always be the 3rd question in the row of essays. So hopefully we've all got it by the next open prompt post.

    I enjoyed reading your critiques, especially the third one. To me, the first essay critique seemed to be filled with too many quoted items from the original essay which made the critique hard a little difficult to understand. It almost seemed like you use too much direct information to argue your point where as in the 2nd essay critique, I which you would have added more specific examples. Despite that, your 2nd essay critique was very easy to understand and you definitely got your point across even without mentioning specific evidence. And lastly, I thought your 3rd essay critique was on point. Funny how it's always 3rd time's the charm, kind of like "Goldy Locks and the Three Bears". You stated concrete evidence and explained them all nicely. Especially nice job on that one. I wish you would have put the actual scores on the critiques and explained why the grader gave that student that exact score though. But overall, nice job! Just lay off a little on the quotes up top there.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Simon, this was a well-written critique of the three open-prompt essays.
    I, like Eddie, have also noticed that first essay is always the best and last worst. I am still trying to figure out the purpose of this trend.
    Anyways, I liked how, like you had advised me to, had about the same amount of analysis for each essay. I’ll try to do that on my next ones.
    Also, I too believe that the second student’s lack of depth cause him/her to make four paragraphs as opposed to the conventional three. Although I look down upon that, I do that sometimes on the SAT and ACT essays when I can’t make elaborate supporting paragraphs. I hope that I will not face this problem on the AP exam, on which the standards are set higher.
    Overall, this was a thorough critique of the three student essays.

    ReplyDelete