In terms of keeping DIDLS in mind whilst analyzing literature, I'm not sure I've been totally successful. I think I still need to work on having a clear definition of each technique at my disposal. Instead, I feel like my analyzing is more "scatter-shot;" when I analyze, I'm like "hey look at this this might do this ooh that's exciting," and then only later can I go back and say "what I pointed out was a use of diction, which contributes to the work's message by . . ." This "method" isn't much of an improvement from what I was doing with literature before this class, which makes me feel like I'm not improving in this area enough.
Our readings on the Theatre of the Absurd and existentialism really lit my brain up. I'd sort of gone through life pretending that I knew what these things were, when in reality I was too lazy to do any research. Only through this required reading did I see how accurate my guesses were, and enlighten myself as to how close my views of the world were to these philosophies. The one that most surprised me with its specificity was the Theatre of the Absurd. I'd assumed that absurdism was just random silliness that held no connection to reality, when in actual fact it has a clear point of view, and strives to convey specific messages through its oft dismissed "nonsensicalness." This new information has forced me to look back on my critiquing ability, and not be so quick to paint something as merely "random nonsense."
Speaking of "random nonsense," I've very much enjoyed our analysis of The American Dream (yes, I understand that it's not random nonsense. I'm just creating smooth transitions). Upon our first reading, I couldn't have ever guessed how deep we'd tumble down the Albee rabbit-hole. The whole thing about Grandma being connected through The Great Gatsby's "owl-eyed man" through her owl-like "who . . . who" still blows my mind. The work has so many messages, and operates on so many different levels, that it would be impossible for me to refer to our discussion as anything less than a pure joy. I've also very much been stimulated by the connections I've found between Dream and modern works with absurdist messages (such as Paul Thomas Anderson's The Master, which opens, cycles back to, and ends on the exact same scene). Without our reading of this play, I would have never received such deep gratification over these connections.
Finally, I should talk about the reading on humor. Though I missed what was probably an enlightening discussion on its connection to Dream, I still found the information endlessly interesting. As much as I like to consider myself a fan of comedy, I'd never been brave enough to delve into the specific theories on what "funny" is. I've always been timid about "gutting the goose" of comedy, which can be an ethereal, unexplainable thing. Regardless, the packets we received do an admirable job at articulating some of the aspects of "funny." So good of a job, that I found connections between its theories and some of my favorite stand-up comedians. It's funny, for instance, when Kyle Kinane talks about how sad and lonely he is, because it's incongruous with the obvious fact that he's a successful working comedian playing sold-out shows most nights (though that's not the only reason. Kinane has an inherent humor about him that I can't explain.) I was also a little surprised that word play, even at the Shakespearian level, is considered "low humor."I suppose I'd been enjoying the unraveling of complex English distortion too much to remark on how devoid of "thoughtful laughter" it is.
Sunday, September 29, 2013
Sunday, September 22, 2013
Open Prompts, Part One: 2006 Student Answers Question 1
1A: The student begins directly answering the prompt from the essay's very beginning, arguing in the first sentence that "[h]umans are often mislead in their feelings of superiority to the world that surrounds them." The student then goes on introduce how he/she will be using examples of diction to support a mood of "dark foreboding," and an illustration of the "fallacy of humans;" and how he/she will be using examples of imagery to support an underlining of "the fragility of mankind." The student proceeds to efficiently and succinctly address each of his/her points, carefully avoiding any deviance from the prompt. The student's body paragraph is rife with specific quotations, and non-meandering language. For example, the student points out how the words "'black, 'scythes,' 'heavy,' 'unforgiven,' and 'darkness' convey a sad scene" that is "heavy with the guilt of human deficiency." The student concludes the essay with a succinct summation of his/her arguments. This essay is of high quality.
1B: The student opens his/her essay with a vague statement that doesn't say much, writing that the poem's language "conveys the mood and meaning by providing the reader with images that give him or her certain feelings," which are "speculative . . . and [of] insecure expectancy." Though the student directly addresses the prompt, the essay's weak introduction and non-specific arguments undercut any level of persuasiveness. As the essay continues, the student uses accurate terminology, but only in reference to a handful of specific quotations. The student's argument feels insufficiently supported, due to only one to two examples used per body paragraph (of which there are only three). The student's closing remarks differ from his/her opening argument, giving the impression that the student began writing the essay without a clear plan in mind, and was eager to finish in a short amount of time. This essay isn't a sign of total incompetence, but has much room for improvement.
1C: The student fails to directly address the prompt. He/she argues that Warren used "complex diction and flowing syntax" to convey an admiration for the hawk's "grace, elegance, and strength," in total ignorance of the poem's mood and a limited understanding of its meaning. From the introductory paragraph it is already clear that the student gave the poem no more than a cursory, surface level glance. The student, playing the role of a tour guide, points out that words like "'angularity,' 'tumultuous,' and 'guttural'" are "not at all simple," and "are, like the hawk, strong and bold." The student's second, and final, argument claims that Warren's lack of periods "shows that the hawk's flight also appears as smooth movement." Though the student's introductory claim is meagerly supported with three examples of diction and syntax, the claim is almost entirely separate from the prompt. The student demonstrates a clear lack of understanding of both the prompt and the source material. This essay is of poor quality.
1B: The student opens his/her essay with a vague statement that doesn't say much, writing that the poem's language "conveys the mood and meaning by providing the reader with images that give him or her certain feelings," which are "speculative . . . and [of] insecure expectancy." Though the student directly addresses the prompt, the essay's weak introduction and non-specific arguments undercut any level of persuasiveness. As the essay continues, the student uses accurate terminology, but only in reference to a handful of specific quotations. The student's argument feels insufficiently supported, due to only one to two examples used per body paragraph (of which there are only three). The student's closing remarks differ from his/her opening argument, giving the impression that the student began writing the essay without a clear plan in mind, and was eager to finish in a short amount of time. This essay isn't a sign of total incompetence, but has much room for improvement.
1C: The student fails to directly address the prompt. He/she argues that Warren used "complex diction and flowing syntax" to convey an admiration for the hawk's "grace, elegance, and strength," in total ignorance of the poem's mood and a limited understanding of its meaning. From the introductory paragraph it is already clear that the student gave the poem no more than a cursory, surface level glance. The student, playing the role of a tour guide, points out that words like "'angularity,' 'tumultuous,' and 'guttural'" are "not at all simple," and "are, like the hawk, strong and bold." The student's second, and final, argument claims that Warren's lack of periods "shows that the hawk's flight also appears as smooth movement." Though the student's introductory claim is meagerly supported with three examples of diction and syntax, the claim is almost entirely separate from the prompt. The student demonstrates a clear lack of understanding of both the prompt and the source material. This essay is of poor quality.
Sunday, September 15, 2013
"Baptism" by Brian Doyle
You can find this funny, reflective essay at: http://theamericanscholar.org/baptism/#.UjXtIGSDSQs
In "Baptism," Brian Doyle skillfully uses rhetoric to re-create the world he lived in as a young boy. Syntax, diction, and imagery all make an appearance in Doyle's humorous painting of a religiously conservative household, teeming with teasing brothers and quirky adults.
In the opening of the piece, Doyle explains that "[f]ew of us remember our own baptisms," following that sentence with: "But I have eyewitnesses to my baptism. . . ." Doyle, using syntax techniques, opens the second sentence with a conjunction. In doing so, he efficiently establishes the relationship between his real memory of his baptism, and what he knows from his trusted witnesses. This also very effectively sets up the essay's premise that Doyle explores: comparing reality with what his family tells him.
Near the end of the essay, Doyle launches into one of his mother's rants about her difficulty hailing a taxi after, presumably, her water breaks, claiming that "there were no taxis to be had. . . ." Doyle could have simply written "she couldn't find a taxi," employing active voice, but he instead chose passive voice. This obscures the responsibility of Doyle's pregnant mother, allowing her rant to take on a more spiteful, Seinfeld-ian tone.
In the second paragraph, Doyle recounts the many stage of his baptism, revealed to him by his oldest brother. This includes "[Doyle] urinating copiously" (Doyle). Why does Doyle inform us that his urination was "copious?" He could have easily communicated the same meaning with "heavily," "a lot," or "all over the place." The word "copious" is the least informal of his other dictional choices, providing a juxtaposition between the silliness of the statement, and the level of its articulation. If Doyle used "a lot" in its place, the joke would instead be about how suddenly Doyle broke from his articulate, well-read voice, to blatantly state that his brother said he peed "a lot."
Doyle elaborates on his brother's other baptismal exaggerations in the final paragraph, saying that "he was baptized by Fulton Sheen, who was passing through New York City on his many peregrinations on behalf of Fulton Sheen. . . ." The word that sticks out the most in that sentence is "peregrinations," the closest this essay comes to elevated diction. It would have been much easier for Doyle to use the words "travels," or "tours," making this word choice seem very deliberate. Either Doyle is using a more elevated, literary tone to poke fun at how pompous and self important Sheen is, or he's pointing out how obviously his brother is lying, as archbishops don't just pass through cities on their own behalf. In either case, Doyle is employing a diction technique for the purposes of humor, painting an accurate portrayal of his brother.
Doyle provides the reader with excellent images in "Baptism." The first one he displays is of a baptized baby Doyle, "draped in a glowing white gown that sure looked like a tiny wedding dress, or grandmother's handmade lace doily" (Doyle). This image is adorable, and provides the proper context for the essay's starting-point. The comparisons Doyle makes to "a tiny wedding dress, or . . . [a] lace doily," both traditionally unmasculine and (from a male perspective) embarrassing things, points to Doyle seeing baptism as silly. If he respected the institution of baptism, he would skip over the silliness of his dress as a baby.
The last third of Doyle's final paragraph is dedicated to one of his mother's rants. He so well encapsulates his mother's personality in the long-winded sentence, that the reader is hit over the head with the image of a sturdy, strong, tired looking woman with one hand on her hip, picking up the tempo of her speech as she gets angrier. This image gives me a sense of overwhelming maternity, of a woman struggling to make ends meet with a house full of kids. This is Doyle's most effective image, pointing to this essay's true purpose: not to describe baptism, but to describe a family.
Brian Doyle's "Baptism" is an excellently written portrayal of a quirky family, that remains consistently humorous in tone. He transports the reader to his childhood effectively and efficiently, using syntax, diction, and imagery techniques in a professional manner.
Monday, September 2, 2013
In Regards to the Poetry Multiple Choice Section
I did reasonably well after totally failing the first one
My biggest, most glaring problem is missing the big picture. I tend to get caught up in the meaning of individual words and syntax, rather than the broad statement the poet is making. For example, in response to the seventh question posed about "La Belle Dame Sans Merci," I betrayed an inability to read past Keats's words and observe that the knight is dead. According to the provided explanation for question seven, this should have been obvious, had I given the poem more than a cursory glance. The same went for "The Chambered Nautilus." Most of my time was spent trying to dissect what a "nautilus" is, and subsequently what a "chamber" could be. A smarter version of myself would have looked up both right away, and continued looking for the true meaning behind the mollusk. Instead, I insisted on reading through the poem multiple times with a guess as to what a nautilus could be, thus providing myself with a completely distorted interpretation of the poem, and entirely sabotaging any hopes for success.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)