Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material

I found our AP Test prep surprisingly in depth. I'd never before been schooled on the numerous variations of "distractors," though I've seen them before on past tests. All of the Multiple Choice advice was hugely helpful for my test taking in general, as the last time I had such instruction I was but a wee little middle-schooler (and it was filled with myths and contradictions). The most useful bit of advice was to not fill in all of the bubbles at the end, as that had been part of my testing technique for years prior. I was also heartened to hear that your first choice isn't usually the best choice. Even in my earlier youth, I had suspicions of such a nonsensical claim. All of our essay prep has also been incredibly useful. I was nervous about my handling of AP Prompts with no AP writing experience at all, but our lessons on how to manage them have allayed most of my fears. I found the most useful portion to be the revelation that all prompts are basically asking "how does the author use techniques to create effects and meaning." This very obviously connects to all future practice prompts and the AP Test itself, which makes it of immense use. 

I've absolutely loved our viewing and analysis of Death of a Salesman. Looking back, watching the film instead of reading in class was an excellent choice, as I got a lot more out of my close-reading with visual backdrop of the film in mind. My only problem with the film is Kate Reid's performance as Linda. She gave Linda a certain harshness that takes away the piles of sympathy the viewer could have for her, and slightly alters the piece's tone. John Malkovich's performance as Biff, on the flip-side, I connected with on a deep level. His performance in the scene where Biff discovers Willy's cheating especially affected me, adding a lot more to my reading of it later. The play itself, on the whole, I found to be quite depressing. Regardless, its allowed me to examine my own life through the lens of Miller's character, giving me insight into the parallels I share with Willy and Biff. Having the background knowledge of The American Dream allowed me to make even more connections, such as the similarities between Willy and Mommy in their distorted pursuit of dominance. Willy's also like Daddy in his many instances of emasculation and failure.


Finally, our reading on tragedy was quite enlightening. I previously lacked any sort of deep education on it's definition (or lack thereof), and tend to lean towards Miller's more liberal interpretation of what makes makes a story "tragic." I connected very much with his rejection of the many structurally specific definitions of tragedy, and enjoyed how he admonishes the notion that a fall from grace may only only be tragic if our hero begins in a position of wealth or nobility. This has opened doors for me in making connections between Miller's take on tragedy and other works, such as the fall of Dirk Diggler in Boogie Nights, and the catastrophic descent of Jerry Lundegaard in Fargo. I'm glad I was exposed to Richard Foster's "response" to Miller's definition of tragedy, as I'd never before seen a somewhat negative review of Salesman. I found his strong resistance to Salesman's inclusion with the "highest" form of literature surprising, and his assertion that close analysis of the piece leads to "confusion, embarrassment, possibly even boredom" to be way overly negative. Foster even goes as far as to state that those who find Salesman to be tragic are "intellectually inadequate," which I found to be thoroughly insulting, and left a bad taste in my mouth. I was never aware of how much mud-slinging there could be in the world of literature, and now have a colorful picture of the extremes of literary criticism. 

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompts, Part One: 2006 Student Answers Question 2

2A: The student begins his/her response strongly with a direct address to the prompt, arguing that "Wilde sheds light on both the characters' underlying ideals and the sort of society that the three of them live in" through "the use of a mundane situation" in which the "characters interact with each other" and share "their opinions." The student proceeds to strongly support his/her argument with specific evidence regarding "Lady Windmere, Lord Darlington, and the Duchess of Berwick," suggesting a strong understanding of the source material. The student stayed consistently on task, citing the "gossip" among the characters as "one example of how trivial their high English society can be." He/she later cites "the women's perception of Lord Darlington . . . [as] highlight[ing] the shallow and critical nature of the society the characters live in." Though more literary techniques could have been explored, the students clear comprehension of the messages hidden in Wilde's dialogue serve excellently in upholding his/her argument. This is a high-quality essay. 

2B: The student begins well with an on-point thesis statement, but doesn't further elaborate on his/her argument well (within the introductory paragraph). As the response continues, the student cites good, specific textual examples to support his/her thesis, but only demonstrates a surface-level understanding of their meanings. Perhaps in some form of compensation, the student continues on to include a total of four specific examples, but each remain undeveloped in terms of his/her thesis. The student concludes with a solid re-statement of the argument. Though the student stayed on task and wrote in an organized fashion, the content of his/her supporting arguments fails to demonstrate a full understanding of the source material, and makes his/her argument feel weak. I agree with the AP Grader in asserting that fewer, but more thoroughly developed, arguments would have served the student better. This is an essay of mid to low quality. 

3C: The student begins with a non-specific thesis that has little to do with the prompt. By only stating that "one can infer the values the characters [possess]" by "reading Lady Windermere's Fan," he/she has completely left out any comment on the nature of the characters' society (which is an exclusion of half the prompt). The student gives a scatter-shot analysis of the Duchess of Berwick and Lord Darlington's character traits, centered around three quotes. His/her inclusion of the quotes was bereft of any in-depth analysis of their subtle nuance and meaning, implying little comprehension of the source material. The student does stick to his/her misguided thesis by stating many "values," but most of his/her claims lack any support ("[The Duchess of Berwick] also enjoys to be a nagging wife.") The student comes close to the prompt by writing that "in society people don't value marriage anymore," but is far removed from any concrete evidence. The concluding paragraph has little relation to the original thesis. This is an essay of poor quality. 


Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Summary and Analysis of The American Dream


The American Dream by Edward Albee is an absurdist/existentialist play, taking place in one scene. The piece stars Mommy, Daddy, Grandma, Mrs. Barker, and Young Man. Their interactions all take place within the living room of an apartment, furnished only with two chairs and a sofa. No specifics on the weather, the season, or the time period are given.

The play begins with a childish, incomplete conversation between Mommy and Daddy. Mommy's topics range from complaining about the breakdown of appliances, to remembering a discussion about the difference between a "wheat" or "beige" hat. Daddy is largely relegated to repeating and listening to Mommy. Grandma enters (with neatly wrapped boxes in tow), and tends to launch into cynical speeches about her view of the world. Mommy dismisses her, saying that Grandma should be taken away by the "van man," and Daddy defends her. We discover that Daddy has some sort of inherited wealth, and Mommy married him purely for his money. Throughout their exchanges, the memory of having invited someone over recurs, but no one completes the thought. Eventually, Mrs. Barker enters the apartment, but can't remember the reason for her visit. As Mrs. Barker attempts to unravel her own mystery, Grandma repeatedly alludes to her knowledge of Mrs. Barker's visit, and its ties to Grandma's boxes. Further along, we discover that Grandma is largely androgynous, and Daddy has suffered from a sex-change operation. Mommy becomes increasingly more aggressive in conversation towards Mrs. Barker. Grandma eventually gives Mommy and Daddy a reason to leave, leaving her to coach Mrs. Barker along in completing her memories. She recounts to Mrs. Barker about a child Mommy and Daddy adopt, and subsequently horrifically mutilate to death  (in a failed attempt to regulate the child's behavior). Mommy and Daddy voice their inability to find anything in the apartment (from offstage), and eventually Young Man knocks on the door. Grandma immediately displays sexual attraction to him, and pegs him as the "American Dream." Young Man launches into an emotional speech, recounting how the loss of his twin left him devoid of any feeling or emotion. Grandma puts it together that Young Man is the twin of the child Mommy and Daddy adopted, and plans to use him as a device to provide resolution to the story. Grandma hires Young Man to an unspecified job, and briefly conspires with Mrs. Barker. Mommy and Daddy meet Young Man, who appears to fulfill both their shallow desires. Grandma exits the realm of the play, and can address the audience. We're left with Mommy, Daddy, Mrs. Barker, and Young Man celebrating their "satisfaction" with wine, and Grandma ending the play with a direct address to the audience.   

The American Dream isn't told from the point of view of a specified narrator (though one could argue that Grandma becomes a narrator of sorts by the play's end), and doesn't take advantage of any leaps in time. From start to finish, the play is chronological. 

Albee's point of view throughout the work could be summarized as sarcastically cynical. He's uncovering the flaws he sees in society by magnifying and distorting them to caricature-like heights. He then drops in an undistorted, fully-formed character (Grandma) to further provide scathing contrast between "normalcy" and his perceived societal flaws. 

Dream's tone feels detached and clinical. Mommy's dominating conversation points come from a place of strategy and ambition, and lack emotion. Young Man is later very on-the-nose with his inability to feel emotion, and describes his state in a very empty, clinical manner. Grandma (arguably the most emotional character of the work) works to find a resolution through rationalization and reason, rather than following her emotions to a more natural climax. 

Many images conjured from The American Dream are mechanical, such as beige/wheat hat, and the continually broken icebox, doorbell, and toilet. The image of Mommy and Daddy mutilating their adopted child evokes deep emotions of disgust, horror, and anger in me. Imagining Daddy receiving a forced sex-change makes me feel pain, pity, and anger. Dream's images tend to align more with material objects (such as the hat, and the neatly-wrapped boxes), which alerts the readers that their attention should be focused on the character's interactions with the material world and its aesthetics. 

The American Dream contains many symbols. Grandma's boxes represent her life's experiences and memories. She's very careful to protect them from damage, and at one point describes them as containing "eighty-six years of living . . some sounds . . . a few images, a little garbled by now  . . .  and, well . . . you know . . . the things one accumulates" (Albee). Grandma makes Young Man remove her boxes from the apartment before she "leaves" the play. Another notable symbol in Dream is Young Man, who Grandma (in on-the-nose fashion) starts calling "the American Dream" (Albee). More specifically, Young Man is the new American Dream; he's purely made of his good looks, and lacks any character, emotion, or job-skills. He is the zenith of human materialism, but lacks any real human qualities. To counter Young Man, Grandma symbolizes the Old American Dream. She's well self-educated, rises above gender roles, and comes from "pioneer stock" (Albee). She's constantly frustrated with the emotional flaws of Mommy and Daddy, and places little value in materialism (her only possessions fit in a few boxes). 

And now, some significant quotes. Daddy: "That's the way things are today; you just can't get satisfaction; you just try" (Albee 16). Daddy's echoing what's almost the ethos of the play: that chasing satisfaction is fruitless. Both the journey and the "attainment" of satisfaction throughout the play is false and meaningless. 
Grandma: "But after they cut off its you-know-what, it still put its hands under the covers, looking for its you-know-what. So, finally, the had to cut off its hands at the wrist" (Albee 61-62). Grandma's recollection of the child-mutilation is bay far the most powerful image of the play, and shines a harsh light on repression in society. Albee's going to lengths to make the point that we shouldn't punish children for natural desires and urges, such as love and sex. The mutilation also makes the reader more willing to divorce the events of the play from reality, giving more leeway to an absurdist interpretation. 

Our decided-upon theme statement: Albee's The American Dream warns that the current generation of Americans has gutted the heart and soul of original American values and replaced them with a materialistic longing  to acquire unattainable satisfaction, but there is hope of change. 

First off, the work's title (The American Dream) frames the whole play as a commentary on American values (past and present), our interactions with them, and how they've changed over the generations. At the core of the play's plot is the search for satisfaction. Mommy, Daddy, Grandma, Mrs. Barker, and Young Man all have satisfactory goals, which they believe to be met by the device of Young Man entering the apartment. Immediately after, however, Mrs. Barker remarks upon the wine's horrible taste, which is Albee's way of saying that these people will continue to invent ways in which they're dissatisfied. The only character who has a chance of satisfaction is Grandma (through her entire leaving of the play-reality), though Albee makes her fate ambiguous. That is the source of this "hope for change." 

Sunday, October 13, 2013

"Romeo and Juliet" by Dana Stevens

You can find this cynical, and bluntly honest film review at: http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/movies/2013/10/romeo_and_juliet_directed_by_downton_abbey_s_julian_fellowes_reviewed.html


"Romeo and Juliet," one of Slate's most recent film reviews by Dana Stevens, takes a harsh look at Hollywood's latest re-hashing of Shakespearean material. Diction, detail, and syntax are all used to make Stevens appear to be intellectually above the film, and to deliver a tired, jaded tone. 

Stevens often switches between higher-end colloquial diction, and informal diction to create a separation between her and Romeo and Juliet. For example, when describing Hailee Steindfeld's looks, Stevens uses informal word-chains with a multitude of hyphens, such as "not-out-of-the-box," and "normal-girl-on-the-street." On their own, these dictional choices would give the piece an informal, down-to-earth tone. However, within the same paragraph (and seemingly within the same breath) Stevens whips out the words "impetuousness" and "petulant." The stark contrast between Stevens's formal and informal diction serves to make Stevens sound "above" such things as Romeo and Juliet, and gives the reader the impression that Stevens would rather be doing other things with her time. 

The details Stevens uses to describe Romeo and Juliet remain almost exclusively dedicated to the film's aesthetics. When describing Douglas Booth (our friend Romeo), Stevens refers to his "model-handsome[ness]," "magazine-ready looks," and "polished . . . manner." Stevens's restraint from delving into the specifics of Booth's performance points to her feelings of jadedness towards today's aesthetically pleasing Hollywood. She's conveying the cynical point of view that popular film makers care nothing for the substance of story-telling, but only for the film's eye-candy factor.

Further along her review, Stevens bring up the beauty of Romeo and Juliet's locations, which span "a few . . . medieval Italian towns,  . . . [which] are gorgeous." Later in the same paragraph, she suggests that it would be more worthwhile for the viewer to admire the beauty that "crowd[s] the walls behind" the characters, rather than focus on their "familiar travails . . . in the foreground" (Stevens). Again, Steven's clear focus on aesthetic details points to her jaded position on the lack of substance in today's films. 

Throughout her piece, Stevens doesn't shy away from long sentences. For example, she opens the review with: 
          Carlo Carlei's Romeo and Juliet—a lush, conventional bodice-ripper of an adaptation with              a screenplay (by Downton Abbey's Julian Fellowes) that borrows heavily from Shakespeare 
          without quite being Shakespeare—feels like a quant throwback to an earlier era in which a 
          little-known director could just up and film a Shakespeare play, without big stars or a 
          modern interpretive concept.
Stevens's use of such long sentences without abandon ensures that she comes across as the film's superior. If she'd chosen to restrain herself, and articulate her ideas in a more concise manner, she would have instead conveyed a tone of impartiality and commonality. By making the intentional syntactical choice of expressing her ideas through long-winded sentences, Stevens has created an atmosphere of intellectual superiority (ensuring that her readers would never confuse her with the type to willingly watch such a film).


Dana Stevens's "Romeo and Juliet" is a well-written review that takes advantage of diction, details, and syntax to portray the author as "above" the film, and create a tone of cynicism towards modern Hollywood.