Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material

I found our AP Test prep surprisingly in depth. I'd never before been schooled on the numerous variations of "distractors," though I've seen them before on past tests. All of the Multiple Choice advice was hugely helpful for my test taking in general, as the last time I had such instruction I was but a wee little middle-schooler (and it was filled with myths and contradictions). The most useful bit of advice was to not fill in all of the bubbles at the end, as that had been part of my testing technique for years prior. I was also heartened to hear that your first choice isn't usually the best choice. Even in my earlier youth, I had suspicions of such a nonsensical claim. All of our essay prep has also been incredibly useful. I was nervous about my handling of AP Prompts with no AP writing experience at all, but our lessons on how to manage them have allayed most of my fears. I found the most useful portion to be the revelation that all prompts are basically asking "how does the author use techniques to create effects and meaning." This very obviously connects to all future practice prompts and the AP Test itself, which makes it of immense use. 

I've absolutely loved our viewing and analysis of Death of a Salesman. Looking back, watching the film instead of reading in class was an excellent choice, as I got a lot more out of my close-reading with visual backdrop of the film in mind. My only problem with the film is Kate Reid's performance as Linda. She gave Linda a certain harshness that takes away the piles of sympathy the viewer could have for her, and slightly alters the piece's tone. John Malkovich's performance as Biff, on the flip-side, I connected with on a deep level. His performance in the scene where Biff discovers Willy's cheating especially affected me, adding a lot more to my reading of it later. The play itself, on the whole, I found to be quite depressing. Regardless, its allowed me to examine my own life through the lens of Miller's character, giving me insight into the parallels I share with Willy and Biff. Having the background knowledge of The American Dream allowed me to make even more connections, such as the similarities between Willy and Mommy in their distorted pursuit of dominance. Willy's also like Daddy in his many instances of emasculation and failure.


Finally, our reading on tragedy was quite enlightening. I previously lacked any sort of deep education on it's definition (or lack thereof), and tend to lean towards Miller's more liberal interpretation of what makes makes a story "tragic." I connected very much with his rejection of the many structurally specific definitions of tragedy, and enjoyed how he admonishes the notion that a fall from grace may only only be tragic if our hero begins in a position of wealth or nobility. This has opened doors for me in making connections between Miller's take on tragedy and other works, such as the fall of Dirk Diggler in Boogie Nights, and the catastrophic descent of Jerry Lundegaard in Fargo. I'm glad I was exposed to Richard Foster's "response" to Miller's definition of tragedy, as I'd never before seen a somewhat negative review of Salesman. I found his strong resistance to Salesman's inclusion with the "highest" form of literature surprising, and his assertion that close analysis of the piece leads to "confusion, embarrassment, possibly even boredom" to be way overly negative. Foster even goes as far as to state that those who find Salesman to be tragic are "intellectually inadequate," which I found to be thoroughly insulting, and left a bad taste in my mouth. I was never aware of how much mud-slinging there could be in the world of literature, and now have a colorful picture of the extremes of literary criticism. 

4 comments:

  1. Excellent job covering the material, connecting it to other courses/life outside of school, and synthesizing material across the course!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Impressive work, Simon. It's pretty hard to constructively criticize a post deemed exemplary by Ms. Holmes herself, but I'll do my best. Perhaps it might have been a good idea to explain how you applied analytical methods from our coursework to our viewing of Death of A Salesman. Can the close-reading techniques we learned about be as effectively utilized when "viewing" a piece of literature? It's an interesting thing to think about. Come to think of it, I should have made that connection in my own response. I'll save it for next time. Awesome job connecting Boogie Nights to our readings on tragedy, by the way. I finally watched it, and it was fantastic. I can't help but chuckle thinking about the differences between Dirk Diggler and Willy Loman, but with regards to tragic elements, both of their stories are rife with them. It would have been really cool if you included some more examples of those elements here in your response, but I can hardly call you out for a lack of specificity. Good work, Simon!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Simon.

    Looking at your post, you did a much better job than me at condensing words and ideas, but still getting your point across. No one wants to read something like mine that's 7 paragraphs long right? I really enjoyed reading about the affects the class has on you and your life outside the classroom; it allows me to think about the many possibilities the discussions may affect my own life too. I would, however, mention a little bit more from the classroom such as the "Promises like Pie Crust" poem. I'm curious as to what you would say for that poem. Or may it wasn't as significant to you as the other pieces we went over (because your class didn't get crust-less pie). But other than that, and my understanding of your connects with something called "Boogie Nights", I really enjoyed reading your post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Simon, this was a well-written response to course materials.
    Personally, I would have preferred doing an in-class quick read to the film. I was not able to understand what some of the characters were saying (I was probably very tired), which affected my inadequate close-reading annotations (I learned new things on the close read, which is not good). However, the discussions we had in class was helpful and I was able to understand not only the play better, but the way to analyze literature in general.
    Also, I too was surprised how deep the lessons on multiple choice questions were. It was interesting and practical for future standardized multiple choice tests (not only the AP Exam, but also the SAT, ACT and GRE in college).
    Overall, this was a thoroughly written response to the course materials.

    ReplyDelete