In "Baptism," Brian Doyle skillfully uses rhetoric to re-create the world he lived in as a young boy. Syntax, diction, and imagery all make an appearance in Doyle's humorous painting of a religiously conservative household, teeming with teasing brothers and quirky adults.
In the opening of the piece, Doyle explains that "[f]ew of us remember our own baptisms," following that sentence with: "But I have eyewitnesses to my baptism. . . ." Doyle, using syntax techniques, opens the second sentence with a conjunction. In doing so, he efficiently establishes the relationship between his real memory of his baptism, and what he knows from his trusted witnesses. This also very effectively sets up the essay's premise that Doyle explores: comparing reality with what his family tells him.
Near the end of the essay, Doyle launches into one of his mother's rants about her difficulty hailing a taxi after, presumably, her water breaks, claiming that "there were no taxis to be had. . . ." Doyle could have simply written "she couldn't find a taxi," employing active voice, but he instead chose passive voice. This obscures the responsibility of Doyle's pregnant mother, allowing her rant to take on a more spiteful, Seinfeld-ian tone.
In the second paragraph, Doyle recounts the many stage of his baptism, revealed to him by his oldest brother. This includes "[Doyle] urinating copiously" (Doyle). Why does Doyle inform us that his urination was "copious?" He could have easily communicated the same meaning with "heavily," "a lot," or "all over the place." The word "copious" is the least informal of his other dictional choices, providing a juxtaposition between the silliness of the statement, and the level of its articulation. If Doyle used "a lot" in its place, the joke would instead be about how suddenly Doyle broke from his articulate, well-read voice, to blatantly state that his brother said he peed "a lot."
Doyle elaborates on his brother's other baptismal exaggerations in the final paragraph, saying that "he was baptized by Fulton Sheen, who was passing through New York City on his many peregrinations on behalf of Fulton Sheen. . . ." The word that sticks out the most in that sentence is "peregrinations," the closest this essay comes to elevated diction. It would have been much easier for Doyle to use the words "travels," or "tours," making this word choice seem very deliberate. Either Doyle is using a more elevated, literary tone to poke fun at how pompous and self important Sheen is, or he's pointing out how obviously his brother is lying, as archbishops don't just pass through cities on their own behalf. In either case, Doyle is employing a diction technique for the purposes of humor, painting an accurate portrayal of his brother.
Doyle provides the reader with excellent images in "Baptism." The first one he displays is of a baptized baby Doyle, "draped in a glowing white gown that sure looked like a tiny wedding dress, or grandmother's handmade lace doily" (Doyle). This image is adorable, and provides the proper context for the essay's starting-point. The comparisons Doyle makes to "a tiny wedding dress, or . . . [a] lace doily," both traditionally unmasculine and (from a male perspective) embarrassing things, points to Doyle seeing baptism as silly. If he respected the institution of baptism, he would skip over the silliness of his dress as a baby.
The last third of Doyle's final paragraph is dedicated to one of his mother's rants. He so well encapsulates his mother's personality in the long-winded sentence, that the reader is hit over the head with the image of a sturdy, strong, tired looking woman with one hand on her hip, picking up the tempo of her speech as she gets angrier. This image gives me a sense of overwhelming maternity, of a woman struggling to make ends meet with a house full of kids. This is Doyle's most effective image, pointing to this essay's true purpose: not to describe baptism, but to describe a family.
Brian Doyle's "Baptism" is an excellently written portrayal of a quirky family, that remains consistently humorous in tone. He transports the reader to his childhood effectively and efficiently, using syntax, diction, and imagery techniques in a professional manner.
Simon,
ReplyDeleteYou picked a great essay to write about in this open prompt blog simply because it was hilarious. Reading the article brought a smile to my face as I related a lot of it to my own crazy, quirky family on, say, Christmas. I loved how you walked through each separate paragraph and explained what happened and what literary techniques were used in each. Bringing in newly learned literary terms is extremely helpful and I thank you for that because it gives me something to remember them with. Although choosing an article may have been the most challenging part of the whole assignment, you chose a great one to write about and your response was very intelligently written. Great job incorporating DIDLS and literary terms!
Simon,
ReplyDeleteI really liked the article that you picked! It was quirky and pretty funny. The paragraph where the brother talks about how large the authors forehead was reminded me of something my older brother would say to me. (Older brothers just loooove to poke fun at the younger siblings!) I think you pointed out everything that I saw when reading the article, so good job with that. The author does use elevated diction and I actually had to refer back to your response just to understand the ah definition of some words. The only suggestion I have is that you should have touched on Brian Doyles use of italics. For example, the very last paragraph stressed the use of italics when talking about the weather and the taxis, and I believe it gave off this sort of sarcastic tone. Otherwise, I loved your response!
Simon,
ReplyDeleteAt first I thought that you just decided not to tell us what the point of the article was, and I figured it was very unlike you. However, at the end of your first paragraph, you proved me wrong, and used a syntactical technique of interrupters to create "suspense" as to what the article was about. Well done! In your introduction, you clearly stated what Doyle used in his essay, and then proceeded to discuss each of these aspects very well. Bringing in things that we've learned in class, such as syntax, diction, and imagery, I can really tell that you have a clear understanding of each of these and can apply them to what you're reading. I think that you have more of an understanding of DIDLS than you think!