Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompts, Part One: 2006 Student Answers Question 1

1A: The student begins directly answering the prompt from the essay's very beginning, arguing in the first sentence that "[h]umans are often mislead in their feelings of superiority to the world that surrounds them." The student then goes on introduce how he/she will be using examples of diction to support a mood of "dark foreboding," and an illustration of the "fallacy of humans;" and how he/she will be using examples of imagery to support an underlining of "the fragility of mankind." The student proceeds to efficiently and succinctly address each of his/her points, carefully avoiding any deviance from the prompt. The student's body paragraph is rife with specific quotations, and non-meandering language. For example, the student points out how the words "'black, 'scythes,' 'heavy,' 'unforgiven,' and 'darkness' convey a sad scene" that is "heavy with the guilt of human deficiency." The student concludes the essay with a succinct summation of his/her arguments. This essay is of high quality.

1B: The student opens his/her essay with a vague statement that doesn't say much, writing that the poem's language "conveys the mood and meaning by providing the reader with images that give him or her certain feelings," which are "speculative . . . and [of] insecure expectancy." Though the student directly addresses the prompt, the essay's weak introduction and non-specific arguments undercut any level of persuasiveness. As the essay continues, the student uses accurate terminology, but only in reference to a handful of specific quotations. The student's argument feels insufficiently supported, due to only one to two examples used per body paragraph (of which there are only three).  The student's closing remarks differ from his/her opening argument, giving the impression that the student began writing the essay without a clear plan in mind, and was eager to finish in a short amount of time. This essay isn't a sign of total incompetence, but has much room for improvement.

1C: The student fails to directly address the prompt. He/she argues that Warren used "complex diction and flowing syntax" to convey an admiration for the hawk's "grace, elegance, and strength," in total ignorance of the poem's mood and a limited understanding of its meaning. From the introductory paragraph it is already clear that the student gave the poem no more than a cursory, surface level glance. The student, playing the role of a tour guide, points out that words like "'angularity,' 'tumultuous,' and 'guttural'" are "not at all simple," and "are, like the hawk, strong and bold." The student's second, and final, argument claims that Warren's lack of periods "shows that the hawk's flight also appears as smooth movement." Though the student's introductory claim is meagerly supported with three examples of diction and syntax, the claim is almost entirely separate from the prompt. The student demonstrates a clear lack of understanding of both the prompt and the source material. This essay is of poor quality.

3 comments:

  1. Simon,
    Following suit with the other years of AP Lit. example essays, 2006 had one great essay, one so-so essay, and one not so great essay. I think this is an important learning tool because when looking at one prompt and three different responses to that prompt, we figure out what is good to include, and what is just useless information that won’t improve your score on the AP exam. I liked how you specifically pointed out the different components of DIDLS in each essay and quoted specific examples of each one. I think referring back to this stuff will be helpful in preparing ourselves for the exam in May because we will recall the difference between just explaining what happened in a certain work (the last essay) and analyzing a work using DIDLS (the first essay).

    ReplyDelete
  2. Simon,
    First of all, I think that you did a good job pointing out the DIDLS in all three essays. Mentioning things like use of syntax and diction is important to me, and helps me try and not forget to use them in the future. Secondly, great job providing us with quotes to help rest your case. Lastly, in your second paragraph you write, "The student opens his/her essay with a vague statement that doesn't say much, writing that the poem's language 'conveys the mood and meaning by providing the reader with images that give him or her certain feelings,...'" and then your last sentence is " The student's closing remarks differ from his/her opening argument,". Maybe next time you could give us the authors final closing remarks and shows us the differences and how they strayed from their opening sentence instead of just telling us.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Simon,
    As expected, you did a wonderful job in critiquing these students' essays. I liked how you strayed from using a specific gender to describe the student. Your use of quotations is well thought out; one could say you even used too many, not that that's a bad thing, either. You ended each of your critiques with a closing statement of how well the essay was written, which allows for people who don't want to read the entire paragraph to just go to the end and see what the whole point of it was. Overall, you wrote clearly and concisely about what exactly was right or wrong with the students' essays, included many quotations to support your argument, and even brought in things we discussed in class (like DIDLS) to analyze the student's writings. Well done!

    ReplyDelete