I did reasonably well after totally failing the first one
My biggest, most glaring problem is missing the big picture. I tend to get caught up in the meaning of individual words and syntax, rather than the broad statement the poet is making. For example, in response to the seventh question posed about "La Belle Dame Sans Merci," I betrayed an inability to read past Keats's words and observe that the knight is dead. According to the provided explanation for question seven, this should have been obvious, had I given the poem more than a cursory glance. The same went for "The Chambered Nautilus." Most of my time was spent trying to dissect what a "nautilus" is, and subsequently what a "chamber" could be. A smarter version of myself would have looked up both right away, and continued looking for the true meaning behind the mollusk. Instead, I insisted on reading through the poem multiple times with a guess as to what a nautilus could be, thus providing myself with a completely distorted interpretation of the poem, and entirely sabotaging any hopes for success.
Your analysis of the poetry section is a bit stronger than your analysis of the diagnostic section--I'm really glad that you felt confident after taking the diagnostic and that you didn't just focus on the negative, but I'd like to see some reflection on areas for growth, too--I felt like I had to wait to read the second entry to get that info, and that the picture might still be kind of incomplete.
ReplyDeleteI'm rather impressed with my ability to predict proper AP poetry reading etiquette; I was spot on in lamenting the importance of getting an initial big picture. For example, reading through "La Belle Dame Sans Merci" with my experience now, it seems quite clear that the knight is dead, as I've been trained to absorb tone and atmosphere initially, before diving into structure and syntax.
ReplyDeleteFor "The Chambered Nautilus," I'm shaking my head really hard at myself for being so easily distracted by the title. It's a sea-creature. Get over it. Again, this is a problem with the initial reading. Now, I'd read the poem, use context clues and basic etymological knowledge to deduce what a "nautilus" is, discern the overall meaning of the work, and then focus on some of the work's minutia.
Regardless of my past-Simon frustrations, I have to again congratulate myself on seeming mostly self-aware of my problems. Luckily, they were all mostly solved by learning proper poetry procedure.
Additionally, I come across as really stressed and high-strung in this post, almost like I'm bending over backwards to impress somebody . . .
I think I'd have to prescribe 10 mL of chilling out. Coming into the poetry reading nervous and expecting failure certainly isn't conducive for success.