Sunday, January 12, 2014

Open Prompts, Part Two: 2004

2004. Critic Roland Barthes has said, “Literature is the question minus the answer.” Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes’ observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author’s treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.

In Edward Albee's play The American Dream, many questions are raised in regards to society. A large, dominating question of the work is: is society beyond saving? Albee seems to imply some answers, but leaves much up to reader interpretation. Albee's treatment of this question affects the reader's understanding of the play's meaning. Albee treats this question through Grandma's final exit, through the last interaction between Mommy and Young Man, and through the role sexual attraction plays in the work's conclusion.

By the end of The American Dream, the readers are treated to a fourth-wall breaking moment from Grandma. She exits the realm of the play, and interacts with the audience. What does this say about society's chances of being saved? It seems to imply that society still has hope, as Grandma was able to escape the hellish reality she was trapped in. Society can indeed save itself from the perils of miscommunication and endless competition. This affects one's understanding of the work by catapulting it to a new level of absurdism. If Grandma had merely "escaped" by leaving the apartment, the impact of Albee's implication would not be nearly as strong as it is now.

The last interaction between Mommy, Daddy, and the Young Man involves a celebration of "satisfaction." Right afterwards, however, Mommy complains that the wine they're drinking doesn't taste good, thus immediately extinguishing any hopes of these characters achieving their goals. This scenario answers the question of society's redemption negatively; The American Dream, based on this portion, implies that society has no hope for redemption. Human beings invent their own problems and obstacles, and shall therefore never overcome their flaws. This treatment affects the reader's understanding of the work in a depressing fashion. It adds a sour note to the play, and pulls readers towards drawing nihilistic conclusions.

The device of The American Dream's conclusion is the Young Man. He temporarily fills the void in Mommy's life, and allows Grandma to exit the story. But, he was granted access into the house initially because of Grandma's intense sexual attraction to him. What does this say about society's redemption? It implies that any redemption will be based on lower desires, such as sex. If Grandma wasn't so initially enthralled with the Young Man's aesthetics, she likely would've closed the door on him quickly. Instead, she was stunned speechless by his looks, and thus was granted enough time to explain his importance to the story. The affects one's understanding of the play by showing how dominated the characters are by sexual desire. It tacks on the notion that, regardless of intentions, all people, wise or naive, are submissive to their basest desires.

The American Dream by Edward Albee proposes the question: is society beyond redemption? By including Grandma's ascension, the final interaction between Mommy and the Young man, and the role sexuality played in concluding the work, Dream gives ambiguous and contradicting answers. Albee's treatment of this question affects the meaning of the work in many ways, leaving much up to the interpretation of the reader.

1 comment:

  1. Simon,
    Perhaps you’ve taken on too grand a task with this prompt, or maybe chosen a work that wasn’t quite right for it. The fact that your question doesn’t seem to have an answer may be an inherent part of Albee’s work, but in my mind, that means that it doesn’t seem to quite fit in with what the prompters want. Your essay was well-crafted, yes, but I don’t think the fact that it is open-ended is good for this sort of essay. I know that you wouldn’t want to do this, but the AP readers are looking for concrete in a palace of shifting sands, and it’s our job as mindless slugs to turn those ever-shifting sands into something definite, which is why I would suggest that you look at different works for this prompt. The American Dream is inherently ambiguous in many aspects, and while it is not impossible to turn that ambiguity into something more definite, ambiguity is not what these AP folks are looking for. I wish it were, though, because many aspects of good literature are inherently ambiguous.

    ReplyDelete