The first student did fine job. He/she began his/her response with a clear reference to the prompt, properly outlining the rest of his/her piece. The student's writing was clear and cohesive for the most part, though his/her average sentence length ran a little too long for my taste. He/she thoroughly explores how the rural setting of Upper Cross in Austen's Persuasion connects with the values of its characters and society, providing many apt plot-examples. These examples include providing the foil of Bath, the work's city setting. This clever device further strengthens his/her argument. The student has a very clear understanding of the setting's function in Persuasion, and commands language well to convey this understanding. I would've him/her an eight or a nine, and the AP Grader gave the student an eight.
The second student did not fair as well as the first. He/she starts off with a solid prompt outlining how the two contrasting settings play an important comedic role in The Importance of Being Earnest, but ends up straying from it for most of the response. His/her first body paragraph is largely devoted to plot summary, failing to strongly link the values of characters with their setting. The student aims at the prompt, but grazes it instead of hitting it dead-on. The second body paragraph is organized in a way reminiscent of a thesis paragraph, sort of restating the point he/she was trying to make. The paragraph then goes on to describe many of the play's comedic situations, and doesn't really add much to the student's argument. The student should've gathered more specific evidence from the play, and organized them more cohesively. Instead, the student had a jumble of ideas the didn't fit the prompt, and weren't organized well. I would have given the student a four or a five, while the AP Grader gave him/her a six.
The third student didn't do well. His/her opening paragraph is thin, and doesn't outline much for the rest of the response. The first body paragraph (or second introductory paragraph) goes on to make the assertion that "nearly every bit of [As I Lay Dying] may be attributed to setting," but then lists a series of unsupportive literary qualities, such as "stream of consciousness," and "dialect." This has little to do with the prompt, or the containing paragraph. The student goes on to list multiple plot points that imply a very keen memory of the work, but never links any of it to setting in a concrete manner. The student made very specific claims towards Faulkner's feelings on the South, but never used any examples in Dying to back up his/her claims. The student took on a flippant, joking tone throughout his/her response, which I found a tad inappropriate. I'm aware that it's dangerous to make academic judgments on stylistic choices, but the student's implied lack-of-caring felt rude to me, and didn't appear to fit well within the context of a college-level test. I would've given the student a three, while the AP Grader gave him/her a four.
One quick side note here, I've peer reviewed your posts before and I asked this previously, but I still don't see it. Can you include the prompt at the beginning of your post? It makes it easier and clearer for me to understand your opinions on the students' posts. OK! Moving on, in your first paragraph you mention that the sentences are too long. Were these run-on sentences or not? Because there is a difference between a personal preference and actual incorrect grammar. Did the students thesis make sense in their essay and did it tie in with their conclusion? I did like how you gave examples on apt plot-examples. I also liked how you included the score they actually received and the score you personally thought they received.
ReplyDeleteI really like your opinions on student number 2. You gave constructive criticism and then suggested that they should have done something else. That actually helps me as an AP student because I can look at what they did and see why that might not be such a good idea, and maybe I should focus on this rather than that.
Finally, your last paragraph was nice and clear on as to why the student did not do well. You provided examples and went on to explain those details. Overall I think you did a great job! :)