2012. “And after all, our surroundings influence our lives and characters as much as fate,
destiny or any supernatural agency.” Pauline Hopkins, Contending Forces
Choose a novel or play in which cultural, physical, or geographical surroundings shape
psychological or moral traits in a character. Then write a well-organized essay in which you
analyze how surroundings affect this character and illuminate the meaning of the work as a
whole. Avoid mere plot summary.
In William Shakespeare's Hamlet, Hamlet's psychological traits are shaped by his royal surroundings. The strictures of politics among Hamlet's family make him feel isolated and paralyzed, transforming his demeanor and tilting him towards murderous urges. Through this shaping of Hamlet's traits, Shakespeare warns that violent revenge can only have negative consequences.
Hamlet's family members often have to wear two different "masks" during their daily life. One represents their public persona, while the other represents their private persona. Seeing as they were often surrounded by court officials, those of high rank in Elsinore had to often adopt completely different views and opinions when speaking to one another. Hamlet, seeing the falseness and denial of intimacy in his family, is driven to frustration and depression by the lack of honest communication in the castle. It is also through this structure of royalty, that Hamlet is denied the experience of love. Ophelia, whom Hamlet impregnated in an act of true love, entirely loses support from Hamlet due to political circumstances out of their control. Had Hamlet been able to spend time with Ophelia and make arrangements to raise the child, he would likely have not been so willing to devote his thoughts to only bloody deeds. Rather, Ophelia drowns herself out of shame and despair, leading Hamlet drown out his former sense of reason and rationale.
For Hamlet, the consequences of his psychological degradation were vast. The scope of his failure is so broad, that it leads to the death of the entire court of Elsinore, and places Denmark into the hands of a rival price without a single shot fired. By comparing the cause and effect of Hamlet's trait changes, the meaning of Hamlet emerges. Shakespeare was indicting the use of violent revenge as a means of justice, and by proxy the mental scarring that politics can inflict. The paralyzing properties of Elsinore lead Hamlet to crave violent revenge, and thus facilitate the meaning of the work. In contrast to Fortinbras, who heeded his Uncle's advice in avoiding violent confrontation, and only visited Elsinore with peaceful intentions, Hamlet emerged the loser. Fortinbras was given the ultimate reward for his actions, and Hamlet the ultimate punishment. Had it not been for Denmark's royal paralyzation on Hamlet, the ultimate message of Hamlet would have been lost.
In conclusion, in William Shakespeare's Hamlet, Hamlet suffers from a psychological shift brought on by the environment of impersonality and politics in Elsinore. This tilts him towards feelings of violent revenge, allowing Shakespeare to communicate that bloody vengeance is not a morally justifiable course of actions.
Simon,
ReplyDeleteYour writing is incredible. Each sentence flows to the next with enough variation in sentence length and structure to keep the reader hooked. I think your essay is strong, but for the AP exam we must analyze literary techniques of the work other than details. If you squeeze in some evidence on DIDLS and how that contributed to Hamlet’s psychological shift and contribution towards the meaning, then this essay would be solid. I think each claim is strong and builds off the next, so the only issue is with your evidence which is an easy fix. Writing for the AP Exam is much different than any other essay because there are special rules like with incorporating DIDLS, so it will feel foreign at first but you’ll definitely get a 9!
Hi Simon,
ReplyDeleteNice essay. I liked that you had a lot of 'fluffy' language that had a lot of references and adjectives however, I thought it was a bit hard to follow but that's probably due to my lack of concentration. I think the AP graders are just looking for you to answer the question and to be straight forward. I'm a little confused as to which question you chose to answer. Correct me if i'm wrong, but It seems to me that you choose cultural surroundings to justify the moral corruption in Elsinore. I seemed to have made the same mistake that you made here. We both didn't add enough DIDLES to support our argument, but your argument otherwise included some very good details from the play. Just keep that in mind and I think you'll do great on the AP!
Simon,
ReplyDeleteYour introduction paragraph is strong and sets up what you plan to discuss in your essay well. I guess I was a little confused by the order of ideas in your essay. In your first body paragraph I expected you to talk about how Hamlet has been essentially raised with the mentality of maintaining a certain image and living a "double life" plus all the psychological damage that brings. However, I felt that your paragraph focused more on the lack of communication that crippled the family. Perhaps, it was just a little clarity in your ideas that I felt was missing. Really I am not sure, but I was a little thrown off at times ( it doesn't take much). Overall this is a nice essay.