Hamlet was WAY more complicated than I thought. I had just watched Joss Whedon's Much Ado About Nothing, and I was all like "I got this guy figured out. Gender swaps and wordplay. That's Shakespeare." But as it turns out, Hamlet's a sophisticated and nuanced piece of literature that would completely go over my head, if not for Ms. Holmes's strong guidance. I'd be lying if I said that a connection to The Lion King didn't cross my mind, but only for some very basic and surface-level plot points. I found a stronger connection with Death of a Salesman, as they both deal with similar themes of personal falseness, the importance of the father figure, and, of course, the death of a father (though it grows flimsier the more I think about it). Another connection I made would be with The West Wing, a show that details the professional and personal lives of US politicians. The characters often struggle to maintain a balance between their personal beliefs and the choices they have to make in the public eye, much like Claudius's battle with his guilt versus his political responsibilities. Ophelia also experiences a similar struggle, having to hide her pregnancy behind a persona of innocence.
Sunday, November 24, 2013
Response to Course Material
I found our second exercise on "atmosphere" to be quite long and frustrating. I was once again schooled at how accomplishing simple tasks, like describing a picture, can be excruciatingly difficult when seemingly simple constraints are placed on our writing. It served as a reminder that while reading Hamlet is all good and fun, AP Lit's also about understanding the mechanics of effective writing, and replicating other authors' use of DIDLS to the best of our ability. It also helped nudge me to the conclusion that I need to improve my ability to work with the rest of the class. I feel like I'm either not talking at all, or totally dominating the room with my ideas. I should try to keep a balance between contributing, yet letting others push for their own ideas. This realization will probably stay on my mind until graduation.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hey Simon,
ReplyDeleteI love how you always find a way to connect your ideas, and that's exactly what this assignment is all about. I actually didn't have any of the same analysis you mentioned between "Hamlet" and "Death of a Salesman", but I think even small connections such as both fathers being dead are valid and not flimsy. They will probably lead to bigger revelations. I would love to read more of your writing ; we did finish the fish bowl discussion and I would have loved to hear what you had to say about that. I could imagine another funny analogy coming from you about that topic. (We had also read "The Century Quilt" poem and wrote an essay, did some multiple choice) What I like so much about you is your personality, and your ability to include your personality and humor into your responses. To me, it seemed like this post was a little formal. Or it could just be me. I also want to say that I, too, need to learn to work better in a large group. As for the Hamlet analysis, I'm definitely going to consider your ideas to help improve my own analysis. So thanks for that!
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHola Simon,
ReplyDeleteI prefer reading how students connected classwork to outside sources more than a play by play on what I already did. However, like Kathy said, I think you are missing a few activities. I agree that I feel a stronger correlation between "Hamlet" and DOS. Willy is the character most likely to be compared to Hamlet, but I see a lot of the emotional misfit in Biff too. As far as class goes, I think you do a good job allowing others to talk. Its hard not be the loudest one in the room when no one else is talking. Good post!