You can read this harsh critique at: http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/books/2013/11/jonathan_franzen_s_first_novel_the_twenty_seventh_city_reviewed.html
"Jonathan Franzen's First Novel Was Terrible," one of Slate's most recent book reviews from Parul Sehgal, doesn't hold back when speaking of Franzen's first novel, The Twenty-Seventh City. Sehgal makes use of diction, details, and syntax to go past a simple negative review, and convey a deep disliking for City's author.
In the review's first paragraph, Sehgal describes City's reissue using some interesting key words. When informing the reader of the novel's new introduction, Seghal uses the words "moist" and "ghastly." These words carry a negative connotation that extends beyond what one would expect from a traditional book review. They seem to imply that Seghal carries some sort of deeper prejudice against the novel, as I imagine not much else would motivate a professional critic to refer to an introduction as "ghastly." Later on, Sehgal describes Franzen's use of researched information as something he "heaves around." Sehgal could have easily used a more neutral term, like "writes," but instead she chose a word that connotes strain, weight, and large size. She's adding negative value to Franzen's time spent researching for the novel, something that extends beyond a simple disliking of the book itself.
When including specific details about City, such as direct quotes, Sehgal is careful to use bits of the book that make Franzen seem especially incapable of writing. For example, midway through the article, Seghel include the quote: "He is haveing no sins but morality." Afterwards, Sehgal is careful to point out that the spelling error was, indeed, found within City. Why use use a quote that happens to contain what is likely the book's only spelling error? How coincidental could it be that a quote with a spelling error was instrumental to this review? Sehgal is purposely painting an overly negative picture of Franzen by choosing to reveal details of his writing that happen to contain trivial errors, which one could just as easily blame on Franzen's editors.
Throughout Sehgal's review, many short sentences make an appearance. For example, midway through the article, Seghal make the blunt statement that "Franzen makes elementary errors." The shortness of that sentence gives it a certain staccato edge, or percussiveness, that lends to an almost aggressively negative view of Franzen. The following sentence reads: "For most of the book, Franzen flails at the controls." Again, Seghal's decidedly limited number of words in that sentence gives the piece a sharper tone, conveying a disliking of Franzen that extends deeper than his poorly written introductory novel.
Parul Sehgal's review of The Twenty-Seventh City, "Jonathan Franzen's First Novel Was Terrible," uses diction, details, and syntax to convey Seghal's deep disliking of Franzen, that extends beyond the novel being reviewed.
In your evidence, you point out that Sehgal wrote this article to take a dig at the author. With such a header, I feel like Sehgal just wanted to make sure Franzen's jaw dropped when they saw the article. It is clear that you read this article with a clear critical eye and saw right through the author's tricky rhetoric. This was especially apparent when you called out Sehgal for quoting the only line containing a spelling error as proof that the novel was poorly written.
ReplyDeleteHey Simon,
ReplyDeleteYour essay seems to be exactly what is recommended for the AP Exam. It is evident that you paid a lot of attention when Holmes was going over this because you have basically everything, including how concise your essay should be. This is great! I know the AP doesn't give you enough time to write a full out, award winning essay, but I feel that you could add a few more examples, but the examples you have are accompanied by great explanations which I think make up for most of that. The only thing that bothered me a bit was the conclusion. It sounds a bit too much like the introduction, and I think the conclusion should connect all three examples with a little more detail than the introduction did after mentioning all your evidence. But other than that, I think you did exactly what students should do on an actual AP Exam, so bravo! And I must add, nice choice in article, this was definitely opinionated.